EXHIBIT 10.4
TAX SHARING AGREEMENT
among
Aetna Inc.,
Aetna U.S. Healthcare Inc.
and
ING America Insurance Holdings, Inc.
--------------------------------
DATED AS OF DECEMBER 13, 2000
TABLE OF CONTENTS
-----------------
Page
----
ARTICLE 1 Definitions
Section 1.01. DEFINITIONS ................................................................. 2
ARTICLE 2 Administrative and Compliance Matters
Section 2.01. SOLE TAX SHARING AGREEMENT .................................................. 13
Section 2.02. DESIGNATION OF AGENT ........................................................ 13
Section 2.03. PRE-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIOD RETURNS ......................................... 14
ARTICLE 3 Tax Return Matters and Tax Sharing
Section 3.01. GENERAL .................................................................... 16
Section 3.02. ESTIMATED PAYMENTS .......................................................... 16
Section 3.03. CERTAIN PAYMENTS UPON DUE DATE .............................................. 17
Section 3.04. PAYMENT OF TAXES AT YEAR-END ................................................ 17
Section 3.05. TREATMENT OF ADJUSTMENTS .................................................... 18
Section 3.06. CARRY-BACKS FROM POST-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIODS AND CERTAIN
OTHER MATTERS ............................................................. 18
Section 3.07. ADDITIONAL MATTERS .......................................................... 20
ARTICLE 4 Certain Covenants and Employee Benefits Matters
Section 4.01. SPINCO COVENANTS TO AETNA ................................................... 20
Section 4.02. COVENANT REGARDING AMENDMENT OF RETURNS ..................................... 20
Section 4.03. CERTAIN DEDUCTIONS RELATING TO EMPLOYEE BENEFITS
MATTERS ................................................................... 21
Section 4.04. CERTAIN TRANSACTIONS EXPENSES ............................................... 22
Section 4.05. CERTAIN OTHER MATTERS ....................................................... 23
ARTICLE 5 Indemnities
Section 5.01. INDEMNIFICATION OF PARENT AFFILIATES BY SPINCO AFFILIATES ................... 23
Section 5.02. INDEMNIFICATION OF SPINCO AFFILIATES BY PARENT AFFILIATES ................... 25
Section 5.03. TREATMENT OF INTERIM PAYMENTS AND REFUNDS WITH RESPECT
TO, AND CERTAIN OTHER MATTERS REGARDING, COVERED TAX ITEMS ................ 26
Section 5.04. DISCHARGE OF INDEMNITY ..................................................... 27
Section 5.05. TREATMENT OF INDEMNIFICATION PAYMENTS ....................................... 27
Section 5.06. CERTAIN ENTITIES AS INDEMNITEES ............................................. 27
Section 5.07. NON-EXCLUSIVITY OF REMEDIES ................................................. 28
Section 5.08. ENTITLEMENTS UNDER CERTAIN AGREEMENTS ...................................... 28
Section 5.09. CERTAIN TRANSFER TAXES ..................................................... 28
Page
----
ARTICLE 6 Subsidiaries
Section 6.01. PERFORMANCE ................................................................. 29
ARTICLE 7 Access to Information and Cooperation
Section 7.01. CONSULTATION AND COOPERATION ............................................... 29
Section 7.02. CORPORATE RECORDS ........................................................... 30
Section 7.03. PROVISION OF INFORMATION .................................................... 30
Section 7.04. CONFIDENTIALITY ............................................................. 31
Section 7.05. PRESERVATION OF PRIVILEGE ................................................... 31
Section 7.06. CERTAIN PAYROLL- AND EMPLOYEE-RELATED TAXES ................................. 32
ARTICLE 8 Tax Proceeding and Consent
Section 8.01. CONTROL OVER TAX PROCEEDINGS ................................................ 32
Section 8.02. NOTIFICATION OF CLAIMS ...................................................... 34
Section 8.03. SETTLEMENT OF TAX PROCEEDINGS ............................................... 34
ARTICLE 9 Payments
Section 9.01. PROCEDURE FOR MAKING PAYMENTS ............................................... 35
ARTICLE 10 Miscellaneous
Section 10.01. AUTHORIZATION ............................................................... 35
Section 10.02. NOTICES ..................................................................... 36
Section 10.03. AMENDMENTS; NO WAIVERS ...................................................... 38
Section 10.04. EXPENSES .................................................................... 39
Section 10.05. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS; NO THIRD PARTY BENEFICIARIES ........................ 39
Section 10.06. GOVERNING LAW ............................................................... 39
Section 10.07. COUNTERPARTS; EFFECTIVENESS ................................................. 39
Section 10.08. ENTIRE AGREEMENT ............................................................ 40
Section 10.09. DISPUTE RESOLUTION .......................................................... 40
Section 10.10. JURISDICTION ................................................................ 40
Section 10.11. FURTHER ASSURANCES .......................................................... 41
Section 10.12. SEVERABILITY ................................................................ 41
Section 10.13. SURVIVAL .................................................................... 41
Section 10.14. CAPTIONS .................................................................... 41
Section 10.15. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE ........................................................ 41
Schedule 1.01A - Certain Agreements Relating to Dispositions Effected by AFS and
Aetna International, Inc.
Schedule 1.01B - Assets Disposed of In Transactions Reportable Under Code
Section 1060
Schedule 1.01C - Certain Agreements Relating to Dispositions Effected
Page
----
by Aetna International, Inc. Subsequent to July 19, 2000
Schedule 4.05A - Calculations Relating to Certain Dispositions
Schedule 4.05B - Certain Additional Matters
Schedule 5.01 - Covered Tax Items
TAX SHARING AGREEMENT dated as of December 13, 2000 (this "AGREEMENT") among
Aetna Inc., a Connecticut corporation ("AETNA"), Aetna U.S. Healthcare Inc., a
Pennsylvania corporation ("SPINCO"), and ING America Insurance Holdings, Inc., a
Delaware corporation ("PARENT").
W I T N E S S E T H :
- - - - - - - - - -
WHEREAS, Aetna and Parent have agreed that all outstanding shares of the
common stock of Spinco shall be distributed PRO RATA to Aetna's shareholders
(PROVIDED that all conditions precedent to the Distribution (as defined below)
have been satisfied), and, pursuant to an Agreement and Plan of Restructuring
and Merger dated as of July 19, 2000 (the "MERGER AGREEMENT") among Aetna,
Parent, ANB Acquisition Corp., a Connecticut corporation and a wholly owned
subsidiary of Parent ("MERGER SUB"), and, for limited purposes, ING Groep N.V.,
Merger Sub shall be merged with and into Aetna, as a result of which Aetna shall
become a wholly owned subsidiary of Parent (the "MERGER");
WHEREAS, for United States federal income tax purposes, it is intended
that the holders of the Aetna Common Stock be treated as having received the
cash consideration from Parent and the common stock of Spinco in redemption and
disposition of the Aetna Common Stock (as defined below);
WHEREAS, Aetna and Spinco have entered into a Distribution Agreement dated
as of December 13, 2000 (the "DISTRIBUTION AGREEMENT"), in which Aetna and
Spinco have set forth the principal corporate transactions effected in
connection with Aetna's distribution to its stockholders of the common stock of
Spinco and certain other matters relating to the relationship and the respective
rights and obligations of Aetna and Spinco following the Merger;
WHEREAS, the parties agree that the interpretation of this Agreement shall
not be affected by the renaming, upon the consummation of the Distribution, of
Aetna as "Lion Connecticut Holdings Inc." and of Spinco as "Aetna Inc.";
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Tax (as defined below) laws of various
jurisdictions, certain members of the Health Group (as defined below) presently
file certain Tax returns on an affiliated, consolidated, combined, unitary,
fiscal unit or other group (each such group, a "CONSOLIDATED
GROUP") basis (including as permitted by Section 1501 of the Internal Revenue
Code of 1986, as amended (the "CODE")) with certain members of the Acquired
Group (as defined below); and
WHEREAS, Aetna, Parent and Spinco desire to set forth their agreement on,
among other things, the rights and obligations of Aetna, Spinco and their
respective Subsidiaries with respect to the handling and allocation of United
States federal, state and local and foreign Taxes, and various other Tax
matters.
NOW, THEREFORE, the parties hereto agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
Definitions
DEFINITIONS
Section 1.01. DEFINITIONS. (a) The following terms, as used herein, have
the following meanings:
"ACQUIRED GROUP" means, at any time, such Parent Affiliates as are
eligible to join with Aetna (or, in the case of a Combined New York-Illinois
Tax, with Combined New York-Illinois Parent) in the filing of (i) for Federal
Tax purposes, a consolidated Federal Tax Return, and (ii) for Combined State Tax
purposes, a Combined State Tax Return.
"AETNA" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"AETNA COMMON STOCK" means the common stock, par value US$0.01 per share,
of Aetna.
"AETNA CONSOLIDATED GROUP" means, at any time, (i) Aetna and each direct
and indirect Subsidiary (including predecessors and successors thereto) that is
eligible to join with Aetna in the filing of (A) for Federal Tax purposes, a
consolidated Federal Tax return, and (B) for the purposes of a Combined State
Tax that is not a Combined New York-Illinois Tax, a Combined State Tax return,
or (ii) for the purposes of a Combined New York-Illinois Tax, the Combined New
York-Illinois Parent and each Affiliate of Aetna that is eligible to join with
the Combined New York-Illinois Parent in the filing of a Combined New
York-Illinois Tax return.
"AETNA GLOBAL BENEFITS ASSETS/LIABILITIES" has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.09.
"AETNA GLOBAL BENEFITS BUSINESS" means the business and operations which
(i) provide services to ALCBL and its customers and (ii) are part of the Spinco
Business (as such term is defined in the Distribution Agreement).
"AETNA INTERNATIONAL DISPOSITION AGREEMENTS" means (i) the agreement(s)
pursuant to which Aetna International, Inc. sold or caused to be sold the stock
of Aetna Canada Holdings Limited to Xxxx Xxxxxxx Canadian Holdings Limited in
August, 1999, (ii) the agreement(s) pursuant to which Aetna International, Inc.,
AE Five Inc. and Aetna Internacional y Compania S. de X.X. de C.V. sold or
caused to be sold the stock of Seguros Monterrey Aetna and Fianzas Monterrey
Aetna to New York Life International, Inc. in January, 2000, (iii) the
agreement(s) pursuant to which Sul America Aetna Participacoes S.A. sold or
caused to be sold the stock of Brasilprev Prevedencia Privada S.A. to Principal
Financial Services Inc. in October 1999, and (iv) other agreements which are set
forth on Schedule 1.01A or Schedule 1.01C and pursuant to which AFS, Aetna
International, Inc. or any of their respective Subsidiaries sold or caused to be
sold stock or other equity interests in their subsidiaries.
"AFFILIATE" means, with respect to any person, any other Person directly
or indirectly controlling, controlled by, or under common control with such
Person.
"AFS" means Aetna Retirement Services, Inc., a Connecticut corporation.
"AFTER-TAX AMOUNT" means, with respect to a payment, any additional amount
(which, for the avoidance of doubt, may be positive or negative) necessary to
reflect the Tax gross-up required to make the recipient of such payment whole at
the appropriate applicable rate(s), taking into account the present value of Tax
benefits and detriments reasonably applied. Any present value calculations made
for purposes of this definition shall be based on discounting at the
Intercompany Interest Rate.
"AGREEMENT" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"ALCBL" means Aetna Life & Casualty Bermuda Limited, a Bermuda
corporation.
"AMRE AGREEMENTS" means the agreement(s) pursuant to which Aetna Life &
Casualty Corp. sold or caused to be sold the stock of American Reinsurance
Company to Kohlberg, Kravis, Xxxxxxx & Co. in 1992.
"AUSHC AGREEMENTS" means the agreements pursuant to which Aetna acquired
Spinco in July, 1996.
"CODE" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"COMBINED NEW YORK-ILLINOIS PARENT" means (i) Aetna Life Insurance
Company, in the case of any tax payable to the State of Illinois with respect to
which one or more Spinco Affiliates are included in the filing of tax Returns
with one or more Parent Affiliates on a unitary basis, or (ii) Aetna Life
Insurance and Annuity Company, in the case of any New York insurance tax payable
to the State of New York with respect to which one or more Spinco Affiliates are
included in the filing of tax Returns with one or more Parent Affiliates on a
combined basis.
"COMBINED NEW YORK-ILLINOIS TAX" means (i) any tax payable to the State of
Illinois with respect to which one or more Spinco Affiliates are included in the
filing of tax Returns with one or more Parent Affiliates on a unitary basis, or
(ii) any New York insurance tax payable to the State of New York with respect to
which one or more Spinco Affiliates are included in the filing of tax Returns
with one or more Parent Affiliates on a combined basis.
"COMBINED STATE TAX" means (i) with respect to each state or local taxing
jurisdiction within the United States, any income, franchise, premium or similar
tax payable to such state or local taxing jurisdiction in which one or more
Spinco Affiliates file tax returns with Aetna on a Consolidated Group basis for
purposes of such income, franchise, premium or similar tax, or (ii) any Combined
New York-Illinois Tax.
"COMBINED STATE TAX PACKAGE DELIVERY DATE" has the meaning set forth in
Section 3.04(a).
"CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT" means Confidentiality Agreement as such term
is defined in the Distribution Agreement.
"CONSOLIDATED GROUP" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"CONTRACT-BASED TAX PROCEEDING" means any Tax Proceeding brought or
arising under any of the Prior Deal Agreements, the AUSHC Agreements or the
Aetna International Disposition Agreements. For the avoidance of doubt, neither
a Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding nor a Taxing Authority Proceeding shall be treated
as a Contract-Based Tax Proceeding.
"COVERED ITEMS DETERMINATION DATE" has the meaning set forth in
Section 5.01(c).
"COVERED ITEMS PAYMENT DATE" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.01(c).
"COVERED TAX ITEM" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.01(c).
"DISTRIBUTION" means Distribution as such term is defined in the
Distribution Agreement.
"DISTRIBUTION AGREEMENT" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"DISTRIBUTION DATE" means Distribution Date as such term is defined in the
Distribution Agreement.
"DISTRIBUTION DOCUMENTS" means Distribution Documents as such term is
defined in the Distribution Agreement.
"EFFECTIVE REALIZATION" (and the correlative term, "EFFECTIVELY
REALIZED") means, with respect to a tax saving or tax benefit, the earliest
to occur of (i) the receipt by any Parent Affiliate or any Spinco Affiliate
of cash from a Taxing Authority reflecting such tax saving or tax benefit, or
(ii) the application of such tax saving or tax benefit to reduce (A) the tax
liability on a Return of any of such entities or of any Consolidated Group of
which any of such entities is a member, or (B) any other outstanding tax
liability of any of such entities or of any such Consolidated Group, which
application shall, for the avoidance of doubt, be treated as occurring on the
due date (taking into account all applicable and valid extensions of such
date) for such Return or the date on which the relevant amount is credited.
"EMPLOYEE BENEFITS AGREEMENT" means the Employee Benefits Agreement dated
as of December 13, 2000 between Aetna and Spinco.
"EVENT" has the meaning set forth in Section 3.06(b).
"FEDERAL TAX" means any tax imposed under Subtitle A of the Code.
"FEDERAL TAX PACKAGE DELIVERY DATe" has the meaning set forth in
Section 3.04(a).
"FINAL DETERMINATION" means (i) with respect to Federal Taxes, a
"determination" as defined in Section 1313(a) of the Code or execution of an
Internal Revenue Service Form 870-AD and, with respect to taxes other than
Federal Taxes, any final determination of liability in respect of a Tax that,
under applicable law, is not subject to further appeal, review or
modification (through Tax Proceedings or otherwise), (ii) any final disposition
of a Tax issue by reason of the expiration of a statute of limitations (giving
effect to any extension or waiver thereof), or (iii) the payment of Tax with
respect to any item disallowed or adjusted by any Taxing Authority where Aetna
and Spinco Jointly Decide that no action should be taken to recoup such payment.
"HEALTH COMBINED STATE TAX LIABILITY" means, with respect to any tax
period and any jurisdiction, an amount of Combined State Taxes determined in
accordance with the principles set forth in the definition of Health Federal Tax
Liability and comparable provisions under applicable law.
"HEALTH FEDERAL TAX LIABILITY" is intended by the parties to measure the
Health Group's standalone Federal Tax liability after applying limitations on
the use of the Health Group's Tax Assets in a manner that equitably reflects
such Assets' actual utilization in the consolidated Return of the Aetna
Consolidated Group. Specifically, Health Federal Tax Liability means, with
respect to any tax period, an amount equal to:
(i) the sum of the Health Group's Federal Tax liability and any interest,
penalties and other additions to such taxes for such tax period computed (A) as
if the Health Group were not and never were part of the Aetna Consolidated
Group, but rather were a separate affiliated group of corporations filing a
consolidated Federal Tax return pursuant to Section 1501 of the Code, and (B)
without taking into account the limitations imposed by Federal Tax law through
the Treasury Regulations promulgated under Section 1502 of the Code (such
Regulations, "CONSOLIDATED RETURN REGULATIONS") (such limitations, "CONSOLIDATED
RETURN LIMITATIONS") (the sum described in this clause (i) constituting the
"HEALTH STANDALONE LIABILITY"); as modified by
(ii) such adjustments, without duplication, for such tax period as are
required to reflect any limitations imposed by the Federal Tax law on the Health
Group by reason of the inclusion of the members of the Health Group in the Aetna
Consolidated Group (the adjustments described in this clause (ii) together
constituting the "HEALTH LIMITATIONS ADJUSTMENT").
The following rules shall apply to the computation of the Health Federal
Tax Liability and shall be deemed to be an integral part of the definition of
the Health Federal Tax Liability:
(1) For purposes of the calculation of the Health Standalone Liability,
(x) the highest rate of tax specified in Section 11(b) of the Code (or any other
similar rates applicable to specific types of income) shall be assumed to be the
only rates set forth in that subsection, (y) the tax
positions taken, and the elections and accounting methods used by, the Aetna
Consolidated Group for the tax period at issue and/or tax periods prior thereto
shall be taken into account, and (z) transactions between any member of the
Health Group, on one hand, and any member of the Acquired Group, on the other
hand, shall not be taken into account.
(2) Without limiting the generality of paragraph (i) above, the
Consolidated Return Limitations shall include limitations relating to (x) the
utilization of net operating losses, foreign tax credits and separate return
limitation year tax items, (y) the treatment of life and non-life subgroups, and
(z) any separate treatment of insurance companies that are described in
Section 1504(b) of the Code.
(3) Without limiting the generality of the definition of the Consolidated
Return Limitations, the calculation of the Health Standalone Liability shall
take into account, and the Health Group shall be entitled to utilize for
purposes of such calculation, among other things, any Tax Asset of the Health
Group as though the Health Group were a separate affiliated group that has
existed and included all relevant members for all relevant periods.
(4) The Health Limitations Adjustment for a tax period shall be calculated
as an amount that reflects (x) the adjustment to the Health Standalone Liability
that shall be required in order for the Health Group to receive the economic
benefit of only such amounts of the Tax Assets or tax items as are necessary to
reflect the actual utilization in the consolidated return of the Aetna
Consolidated Group for such tax period, and (y) the excess loss accounts or
deferred intercompany gains or intercompany items of members of the Health Group
that are actually triggered during such tax period under the Consolidated Return
Regulations and are taken into account in the consolidated return of the Aetna
Consolidated Group.
(5) In calculating the Health Limitations Adjustments, except to the
extent mutually agreed upon by Aetna and Spinco, the tax positions taken, and
the elections and accounting methods used shall be consistent with those (x)
used by the Aetna Consolidated Group for the tax period at issue and/or tax
periods prior thereto, and (y) used in the computation of the Health Standalone
Liability.
(6) The parties hereto shall be permitted to invoke the dispute
resolution procedures under Section 10.09 with respect to any disagreement in
the methodology used in calculating Health Federal Tax Liability hereunder.
For the avoidance of doubt, this rule (6) is not intended to affect the
application of the third and fourth sentences of Section 2.03(b).
"HEALTH GROUP" means, at any time, such Spinco Affiliates as are eligible
to join with Aetna (or, in the case of a Combined New York-Illinois Tax, with
the Combined New York-Illinois Parent) in the filing of (i) for Federal Tax
purposes, a consolidated Federal Tax Return, and (ii) for Combined State Tax
purposes, a Combined State Tax Return.
"HEALTH GROUP TAX LIABILITY" means, with respect to any tax period, the
sum of (i) the Health Federal Tax Liability, and (ii) the Health Combined State
Tax Liability.
"INDEMNITEE" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.04.
"INDEMNITOR" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.04.
"INTERCOMPANY INTEREST RATE" means 8% (compounded annually), or an
economically equivalent interest rate with respect to a compounding period that
is shorter than one year.
"JOINTLY DECIDE" means, with respect to specified parties, arriving at a
prompt and timely decision to which each such party agrees after such party has
(i) received relevant information available to the other parties and
(ii) discussed with the other parties any relevant financial or other aspects
of such decision and any alternatives thereto raised by the parties. In the
event that the specified parties are unable to reach agreement on a matter on
which they Jointly Decide, (A) any party may invoke the dispute resolution
procedures set forth in Section 10.09 of this Agreement, or (B) the part(ies)
that disagree with a decision shall be deemed to have agreed with such
decision if one or more of the other parties furnish an indemnity, reasonably
satisfactory to the recipient(s) thereof, in respect of any Tax liability and
the related After-Tax Amount that may result from such decision (PROVIDED
that the determination as to whether an indemnity is reasonably satisfactory
to the recipient(s) thereof (x) may be subject to the dispute resolution
procedures set forth in Section 10.09 of this Agreement and (y) shall be
based upon, among other things, the scope of the indemnity and the financial
credit of the part(ies) furnishing the indemnity).
"LINCOLN AGREEMENTS" means the agreements pursuant to which Aetna Life
Insurance Company and Aetna Life Insurance and Annuity Company ceded domestic
life insurance businesses to, and effected related transactions with, Lincoln
National Life Insurance Company and Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York
in October, 1998.
"MERGER" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"MERGER AGREEMENT" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"MERGER SUB" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"MISCELLANEOUS AGREEMENTS" means (i) the agreement(s) pursuant to which
certain Texas healthcare assets owned by Spinco as a result of the acquisition
described in the NYLCare Agreements were sold to Blue Cross and Blue Shield of
Texas, a division of Health Care Service Corporation, in March, 2000, and (ii)
other agreements as set forth on Schedule 1.01B or any agreements (other than
the Lincoln Agreements, the NYLCare Agreements and the Prudential Agreements)
pursuant to which Aetna Life Insurance Company, Aetna Health and Life Insurance
Company, Spinco or their respective direct or indirect Subsidiaries sold or
acquired stock (or equity interests) in, or assets of, other corporations or
unincorporated entities.
"NEW LLC" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.09.
"NYLCARE AGREEMENTS" means the agreements pursuant to which Aetna acquired
the healthcare assets of New York Life Insurance Company in July, 1998.
"PARENT" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"PARENT AFFILIATES" means, without duplication, (i) Aetna, AFS, Aetna
Retirement Holdings, Inc., Aetna Life Insurance and Annuity Company, Aetna
International, Inc., Aetna Life Insurance Company of America and any other
direct and indirect Subsidiaries of Parent immediately after the Distribution
(including predecessors and successors thereto), (ii) any entities that are
or have been "controlled foreign corporations" (within the meaning of
Section 957(a) of the Code or successor provisions) of which AFS, Aetna
International, Inc. or any of their respective Subsidiaries is or has been a
"United States shareholder" (within the meaning of Section 951(b) of the Code
or successor provisions), (iii) China Pacific Insurance Company, and (iv) any
entities (except for entities described in clause (i) or clause (ii) of this
definition) that have been direct or indirect Subsidiaries of AFS or Aetna
International, Inc. at any time prior to the Distribution (including
predecessors or successors thereto). Aetna Services, Inc. shall be treated as
a Parent Affiliate for tax periods ending prior to January 1, 2000.
"PERSON" means Person as such term is defined in the Distribution
Agreement.
"POST-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIOD" means (i) any tax period beginning and
ending after the Distribution Date, and (ii) with respect to a tax period that
begins before and ends after the Distribution Date, such portion of the
tax period that commences on the day immediately after the Distribution Date.
"POST-1994 TAX PERIOD" means any tax period (or portion thereof) that
begins on or after January 1, 1995.
"PRE-DISTRIBUTION STUB TAX PERIOD" means any tax period described in
clause (ii) of the definition of Pre-Distribution Tax Period.
"PRE-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIOD" means (i) any tax period ending before or on
the Distribution Date, and (ii) with respect to a period that begins before and
ends after the Distribution Date, such portion of the tax period ending on and
including the Distribution Date.
"PRE-1995 TAX PERIOD" means any tax period (or portion thereof) that ends
on or before December 31, 1994.
"PRIOR DEAL AGREEMENTS" means (i) the AmRe Agreements, (ii) the Lincoln
Agreements, (iii) the NYLCare Agreements, (iv) the Prudential Agreements, (v)
the Travelers Agreements, and/or (vi) the Miscellaneous Agreements.
"PRUDENTIAL AGREEMENTS" means the agreements pursuant to which Aetna and
certain of its Subsidiaries acquired the healthcare assets of The Prudential
Insurance Company of America in August, 1999.
"REFEREE" has the meaning set forth in Section 10.09.
"REPRESENTATIVES" has the meaning set forth in Section 7.04.
"RETURN" means any Tax return, statement, report or form (including
without limitation estimated Tax returns and reports, extension requests and
forms, and information returns and reports) required to be filed with any Taxing
Authority.
"RETURN DUE DATE" means, with respect to a return of the Aetna
Consolidated Group, the due date under applicable Tax law of such Return (taking
into account, without limitation, all applicable and valid extensions of such
date).
"SPECIFIED DEDUCTION" has the meaning set forth in Section 4.03.
"SPINCO" has the meaning set forth in the recitals.
"SPINCO AFFILIATES" means (i) Spinco, Aetna Life Insurance Company, Aetna
Health and Life Insurance Company and any other direct or indirect Subsidiaries
of Spinco immediately after the Distribution
(including predecessors and successors thereto), (ii) the Travelers Companies
(including predecessors or successors thereto), and (iii) any entities (except
for entities described in clause (i) or clause (ii) of this definition) that
have been direct or indirect Subsidiaries of Aetna at any time prior to the
Distribution (including predecessors or successors thereto) but that are not
Parent Affiliates. Aetna Services, Inc. shall be treated as a Spinco Affiliate
for tax periods beginning after December 31, 1999.
"SPINCO-AETNA TAX PROCEEDING" means any Tax Proceeding solely between (i)
one or more of the Parent Affiliates, ING Groep N.V. and/or any entity that,
following the Distribution Date, is a Subsidiary of ING Groep N.V., on one hand,
and (ii) one or more of the Spinco Affiliates, and/or any entity that, following
the Distribution Date, is a Subsidiary of Spinco, on the other hand.
"SPIN-OFF" means Spin-Off as such term is defined in the Merger Agreement.
"SUBSIDIARY" means Subsidiary as such term is defined in the Distribution
Agreement.
"TAX" means (i) any United States federal, state or local or foreign
income, profits, franchise, premium, gross receipts, environmental, customs
duty, capital stock, severances, stamp, payroll, sales, transfer, employment,
unemployment, occupation, disability, use, property, real property gains,
withholding, escheat, excise, production, value added, ad valorem, windfall,
license, occupancy and any other taxes, duties or assessments of any nature
whatsoever, together with any interest, penalties and additions imposed with
respect to such amounts and any interest in respect of such penalties and
additions; (ii) any liability of an entity for the payment of any amount of the
type described in clause (i) as a result of being or having been before the
Distribution Date a member of a Consolidated Group, or a party to any agreement
or arrangement, as a result of which liability of such entity and its
subsidiaries to a Tax Authority is determined or taken into account with
reference to the liability of any other Person (including, for example,
liability under Treasury Regulations Section 1.1502-6 or similar liability under
any other law), and (iii) any liability for the payment of any amount as a
result of being party to any agreements or arrangements (whether or not written)
binding an entity or any of its subsidiaries (A) that provide for the
allocation, apportionment, sharing or assignment of any tax liability or tax
benefit, or the transfer or assignment of income, revenues, receipts, or gain,
in each case for the principal purpose of determining any Person's tax liability
or (B) with respect to the payment of any amount of the type described in clause
(i)
or clause (ii) as a result of any existing express or implied obligation
(including without limitation an indemnification obligation).
"TAX ASSET" means any net operating loss, net capital loss, investment tax
credit, foreign tax credit, enterprise zone credit or incentive, charitable
deduction or any other loss, credit, deduction or tax attribute that could be
carried forward or back to reduce taxes (including without limitation deductions
and credits relating to alternative minimum taxes).
"TAX PACKAGES" of the Health Group with respect to a tax period means (i)
in the context of the preparation of a Tax return, one or more packages
(sufficiently complete to be filed in a Return) which shall include (A)
completed Federal Tax Forms 1120s, 1120-PCs and 1120-Ls or comparable state Tax
forms, as the case may be (or materials reflecting the information set forth on
such forms), prepared on a pro forma basis, and (B) such other schedules and
other materials, containing information with respect to the Health Group
relevant to the preparation and signing of the Returns of the Aetna Consolidated
Group with respect to such tax period, as are reasonably necessary to calculate
consolidated Taxable items and as are mutually agreed to, and (ii) in the
context of the determination of the amount of any payment of estimated taxes,
one or more packages of Tax information, to be mutually agreed to, which enable
the calculation of such estimated taxes.
"TAX PROCEEDING" means any Tax audit, contest, dispute or proceeding
(whether administrative, judicial or otherwise).
"TAXING AUTHORITY" means any governmental authority (whether United States
or foreign, and including without limitation any state, municipality, political
subdivision or governmental agency) responsible for the imposition of any Tax.
"TAXING AUTHORITY PROCEEDING" means any Tax Proceeding in which a Taxing
Authority participates.
"TRANSFER TAXES" has the meaning set forth in Section 5.09.
"TRAVELERS AGREEMENTS" means the agreements pursuant to which Aetna sold
or caused to be sold the stock of the Travelers Companies to The Travelers
Insurance Group, Inc. in April, 1996.
"TRAVELERS COMPANIES" means The Aetna Casualty and Surety Company, The
Standard Fire Insurance Company and their respective Subsidiaries.
(b) Any term used in this Agreement that is not defined in this Agreement
shall, to the extent the context requires, have the meaning assigned to it in
the Code (and applicable Treasury regulations thereunder) or comparable
provisions of applicable state or local or foreign tax law.
ARTICLE 2
Administrative and Compliance Matters
Section 2.01. SOLE TAX SHARING AGREEMENT. Any and all existing Tax
sharing agreements or arrangements, written or unwritten, between one or more
Parent Affiliates and one or more Spinco Affiliates shall be terminated as of
the effective date of this Agreement; PROVIDED that there shall not be
terminated any Tax sharing agreements or arrangements that are included or
set forth in the Prior Deal Agreements or in the Aetna International
Disposition Agreements, or (ii) to the extent consistent with the provisions
and principles of this Agreement, any provision relating to Taxes in the
Distribution Agreement, the other Distribution Documents or the Merger
Agreement. As of the effective date of this Agreement, neither the Parent
Affiliates nor the Spinco Affiliates shall have any further rights or
liabilities under agreements or arrangements that are terminated pursuant to
the preceding sentence, and this Agreement shall be the sole Tax sharing
agreement between one or more Parent Affiliates, on one hand, and one or more
Spinco Affiliates, on the other hand.
(b) This Agreement shall not address the obligations or arrangements, if any,
(i) among Parent Affiliates, or (ii) among Spinco Affiliates.
Section 2.02. DESIGNATION OF AGENT. (a) Each member of the Health Group
hereby authorizes and designates Aetna as its agent, coordinator and
administrator, for the purposes of (i) taking any and all actions necessary
or incidental to the filing of any Return, any amended Return or any claim
for refund, credit or offset of Tax, or any other proceedings, and (ii)
making payments to, or collecting refunds from, any Taxing Authority, in the
case of each of clauses (i) and (ii) relating only to any Pre-Distribution
Tax Period and in conformity with the provisions and principles of this
Agreement; PROVIDED that, for the avoidance of doubt, Aetna shall not be
designated as agent, coordinator or administrator with respect to Taxes
reflected on any Federal Tax Return, United States state or local Tax Return
or Return relating to foreign Taxes, in each case that are (A) filed on a
separate-company basis by a member of the Health Group, or (B) filed on
behalf of a Consolidated Group of which a member of the Health Group is the
parent. Aetna covenants to the Spinco Affiliates that it shall be responsible
to see that all administrative matters
relating to the actions described in clauses (i) and (ii) of the preceding
sentence shall be handled promptly and appropriately and in conformity with the
provisions and principles of this Agreement. Any disputes between Aetna and the
Health Group as to the scope of Aetna's role under this Section 2.02 shall be
the subject of the dispute resolution procedures under Section 10.09.
(b) Combined New York-Illinois Parent shall be designated as agent,
coordinator and administrator of each member of the Health Group, in the case
of a Combined New York-Illinois Tax that is the New York insurance tax, or
each member of the Acquired Group, in the case of a Combined New
York-Illinois Tax that is the tax payable to the State of Illinois, for the
purposes of (i) taking any and all actions necessary or incidental to the
filing of any Return, any amended Return or any claim for refund, credit or
offset of a Combined New York-Illinois Tax, or any other proceedings, and
(ii) making payments to, or collecting refunds from, any Taxing Authority, in
the case of each of clauses (i) and (ii) relating only to any
Pre-Distribution Tax Period and in conformity with the provisions and
principles of this Agreement. In applying Section 2.03 and/or Article 3
(and/or any other provision of this Agreement for which the parent of the
Consolidated Group with respect to a Combined New York-Illinois Tax is
relevant) to a Combined New York-Illinois Tax, (i) a reference in any such
provision to Aetna shall be treated, as appropriate, as a reference to the
Combined New York-Illinois Parent, and (ii) any such provision shall be
applied MUTATIS MUTANDIS with respect to such Combined New York-Illinois Tax.
(c) Aetna and Spinco shall Jointly Decide the extent, if any, to which
Aetna shall be designated as agent, coordinator and administrator of members of
the Health Group for the purpose of taking actions relating to any
Post-Distribution Tax Period.
Section 2.03. PRE-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIOD RETURNS. (a) Aetna shall
prepare, consistently with relevant past practice and applicable law and in
conformity with the provisions and principles of this Agreement, and file the
consolidated Federal Tax Returns and Combined State Tax Returns of the Aetna
Consolidated Group for all Pre-Distribution Tax Periods.
(b) In preparing such Returns, Aetna shall not discriminate among the
members of the Aetna Consolidated Group. Aetna shall have the right with respect
to such Returns to determine (i) the manner in which such Returns shall be
prepared and filed on Tax matters that predominantly affect the Acquired Group,
including without limitation the manner in which any item of income, gain, loss,
deduction or credit shall be reported by the Acquired Group, and (ii) the
elections that shall be made by any member of the Acquired Group. Spinco shall
have the right, with respect to all Federal Tax Returns and Combined State Tax
Returns of the Aetna
Consolidated Group for Pre-Distribution Tax Periods, to determine (i) the manner
in which such Returns shall be prepared and filed on Tax matters that
predominantly affect the Health Group, including without limitation the manner
in which any item of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit shall be reported
by the Health Group (PROVIDED, however, that Spinco shall not have such right
with respect to, and Spinco and Aetna shall Jointly Decide the treatment of, a
Tax matter (or the relevant portion thereof) on a Return to the extent that (A)
(x) there is not substantial authority in support of Spinco's position on such
Tax matter (or portion thereof), and (y) Spinco has not included appropriate
disclosure of such position in the relevant Tax Package, or (B) there is not
reasonable basis for Spinco's position), and (ii) the elections that shall be
made by any member of the Health Group. The parties agree that the Spin-Off
shall be treated as predominantly relating to the Health Group for the purposes
of this Agreement.
(c) To the extent that (i) two or more provisions of Section 2.03 (b)
would otherwise apply to a Tax item in a conflicting manner, or the treatment
of a Tax item that is material to the tax liability of the Aetna Consolidated
Group for the relevant Pre-Distribution Tax Period is not addressed by
Section 2.03 (b), and (ii) the treatment of such Tax item in the appropriate
Return of the Aetna Consolidated Group is not addressed by any other
provision of this Agreement, Aetna and Spinco shall Jointly Decide the
treatment of such Tax item.
(d) No later than 45 calendar days prior to the Return Due Date for a
Return of the Aetna Consolidated Group, Spinco shall prepare and deliver Tax
Packages to Aetna that contain information of the Health Group for (i) any
Pre-Distribution Stub Tax Period, and (ii) any other tax period for which
(A) a Return that includes such tax period has not been filed prior to the
Distribution Date and (B) any Spinco Affiliate is part of the Aetna
Consolidated Group. Subject to Section 2.03(c), the Tax information
contained in such Tax Packages shall be presumed for purposes of
Section 2.03(b) to constitute Tax matters that predominantly affect the
Health Group; PROVIDED that Aetna may rebut such presumption, as appropriate,
using the dispute resolution procedures under Section 10.09 of this Agreement.
(e) No later than 25 calendar days prior to the Return Due Date for a
Return of the Aetna Consolidated Group with respect to a taxable year that
includes a Pre-Distribution Tax Period, Aetna shall provide Spinco with a draft
of such Return, together with material supporting calculations and any other
information reasonably requested by Spinco. Spinco shall have the opportunity to
review and comment on such draft Return, including without limitation to
determine whether such draft Return reflects, in conformity with the provisions
and principles of this Agreement, (i) the information set forth, or otherwise
reflected in, the corresponding Tax Package furnished by Spinco, and (ii) the
treatment of Tax items that have been Jointly Decided by Aetna and Spinco. Aetna
shall take into
account, and as necessary shall modify the Return to reflect, such comments
made by Spinco as are required by this Agreement. Any disagreements or
disputes regarding the scope of Spinco's review and comment rights under this
Section 2.03(e) shall be subject to the dispute resolution procedures under
Section 10.09.
ARTICLE 3
Tax Return Matters and Tax Sharing
Section 3.01. GENERAL. For each taxable year of the Aetna Consolidated
Group during which income, loss or credit against tax of any member of the
Health Group is includible in the consolidated Federal Tax Return of the
Aetna Consolidated Group, Spinco shall pay to Aetna an amount equal to the
Health Federal Tax Liability, as shown on the calculations described in
Section 3.04(a) that result from the Tax Packages of the Health Group for
(i) such taxable year, if such taxable year ends prior to the Distribution
Date, or (ii) the Pre-Distribution Stub Tax Period, if such taxable year
includes the Distribution Date. For each taxable year of the Aetna
Consolidated Group during which income, loss or credit against tax of any
member of the Health Group is includible in a Return relating to a Combined
State Tax, Spinco shall pay Aetna an amount equal to the Health Combined
State Tax Liability, as shown on the calculations described in
Section 3.04(a) that result from the Tax Packages of the Health Group for
(i) such taxable year, if such taxable year ends prior to the Distribution
Date, or (ii) the Pre-Distribution Stub Tax Period, if such taxable year
includes the Distribution Date. The principles, and as relevant the
provisions, of Section 2.03 shall be applied in interpreting this Article.
For the avoidance of doubt, any reference to the principles of this
Section 3.01 shall include a reference to the applicable principles of
Section 2.03.
Section 3.02. ESTIMATED PAYMENTS. Aetna shall determine the amount of
the estimated tax installment of the Health Federal Tax Liability
(corresponding to the Aetna Consolidated Group's estimated Federal Tax
installment) with respect to a taxable year in which the Health Group is part
of the Aetna Consolidated Group (whether or not such payment is made prior to
the Distribution Date), as determined under the principles of Section 3.01 of
this Agreement and using a Tax Package for the Health Group with respect to
the appropriate tax period timely furnished by Spinco to Aetna. Aetna shall
provide Spinco with notice of such estimated determination for Federal Tax no
later than 30 calendar days before the date such corresponding installment
payment is due (including all applicable and valid extensions). Spinco shall,
on or prior to the due date of the Aetna Consolidated Group's corresponding
installment payment, pay to Aetna the amount so determined in accordance with
Article 9
hereof. Aetna shall determine the amount of the estimated tax installment of
the Health Combined State Tax Liability (corresponding to the Aetna
Consolidated Group's relevant estimated Combined State Tax installment) with
respect to a taxable year in which the Health Group is part of the Aetna
Consolidated Group (whether or not such payment is made prior to the
Distribution Date), as determined under the principles of Section 3.01 of
this Agreement and using a Tax Package for the Health Group with respect to
the appropriate tax period timely furnished by Spinco to Aetna. Aetna shall
provide Spinco with notice of such estimated determination for Combined State
Tax no later than 15 calendar days before the date such corresponding
installment payment is due (including all applicable and valid extensions).
Spinco shall, on or prior to the due date of the Aetna Consolidated Group's
corresponding installment payment, pay to Aetna he amount so determined in
accordance with Article 9 hereof.
Section 3.03. CERTAIN PAYMENTS UPON DUE DATE. On or prior to the due
date under Tax law (without taking into account any applicable or valid
extensions of such date) of any Return of the Aetna Consolidated Group with
respect to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period, Spinco shall pay to Aetna, or Aetna
shall pay to Spinco, as appropriate, an amount equal to the difference, if any,
between (i) the Health Federal Tax Liability or the Health Combined State Tax
Liability, as the case may be, for such Pre-Distribution Tax Period, and
(ii) the aggregate amount of the estimated installments paid with respect
thereto pursuant to (or in accordance with the principles of) Section 3.02.
Section 3.04. PAYMENT OF TAXES AT YEAR-END. (a) No later than 45 calendar
days before the Return Due Date for the Aetna Consolidated Group's
consolidated Federal Tax return, Spinco shall deliver to Aetna a Tax Package
of the Health Group relating to Federal Taxes for (i) such taxable year, if
such taxable year ends prior to the Distribution Date, or (ii) the
Pre-Distribution Stub Tax Period, if such taxable year includes the
Distribution Date (the delivery date constituting the "FEDERAL TAX PACKAGE
DELIVERY DATe"). No later than 30 calendar days after the Federal Tax Package
Delivery Date, Aetna shall deliver to Spinco a statement showing a
calculation of the amount to be paid pursuant to Section 3.04(b) below. No
later than 45 calendar days before the Return Due Date for each Combined
State Tax return, Spinco shall deliver to Aetna a Tax Package of the Health
Group relating to a Combined State Tax for (i) such taxable year, if such
taxable year ends prior to the Distribution Date, or (ii) the
Pre-Distribution Stub Tax Period, if such taxable year includes the
Distribution Date (the delivery date constituting a "COMBINED STATE TAX
PACKAGE DELIVERY DATe"). No later than 20 calendar days after such Combined
State Tax Package Delivery Date, Aetna shall deliver to Spinco
a statement showing a calculation of the amount to be paid pursuant to
Section 3.04(b) below. In the event that Aetna and Spinco Jointly Agree that
any timeframe set forth in this Section 3.04(a) shall be modified, this
Section 3.04(a) shall be treated as having been satisfied to the extent such
modified timeframe is complied with.
(b) On or prior to the Return Due Date for the Return of the Aetna
Consolidated Group to which a calculation described in Section 3.04(a),
resulting from a Tax Package of the Health Group, relates, Spinco shall pay to
Aetna, or Aetna shall pay to Spinco, as appropriate, an amount equal to the
difference, if any, between (i) the Health Federal Tax Liability or the Health
Combined State Tax Liability, as the case may be, reflected by such calculation
for such tax period, and (ii) the aggregate amount of (A) the estimated
installments paid with respect thereto pursuant to (or in accordance with the
principles of) Section 3.02, and (B) payments made pursuant to (or in accordance
with the principles of) Section 3.03.
(c) Spinco shall be permitted to invoke the dispute resolution procedures
under Section 10.09 with respect to the manner in which Aetna has discharged its
obligations under Section 3.04(a).
Section 3.05. TREATMENT OF ADJUSTMENTS. If any adjustment is made in a
Federal Tax Return or a Combined State Tax Return of the Aetna Consolidated
Group, after the filing thereof, in which income or loss of any member of the
Health Group is included, then within five calendar days of the time of a
Final Determination of such adjustment, Spinco shall pay to Aetna or Aetna
shall pay to Spinco, as the case may be, the difference between all payments
actually made pursuant to (or in accordance with the principles of) Article 3
(and any other applicable provisions of this Agreement) with respect to the
taxable year covered by such Return and all payments that would have been
made pursuant to (or in accordance with the principles of) Article 3 (and any
other applicable provisions of this Agreement) taking such adjustment into
account with respect to such taxable year, together with any penalties
actually paid and interest for each day until the date of Final Determination
calculated at the Intercompany Interest Rate.
Section 3.06. CARRY-BACKS FROM POST-DISTRIBUTION TAX PERIODS AND
CERTAIN OTHER MATTERS. (a) Aetna agrees to pay to Spinco, within three
calendar days of Effective Realization, the actual tax benefit received or
otherwise Effectively Realized by the Aetna Consolidated Group from the use
in any Pre-Distribution Tax Period of a carryback of any Tax Asset of the
Health Group from a Post-Distribution Tax Period. Such benefit shall be equal
to the excess of (i) the amount of Federal Taxes or Combined State Taxes, as
the case may be, that would have been payable (or of the Federal Tax or
Combined State Tax refund actually receivable) by the Aetna Consolidated
Group in the absence of such carryback, over (ii) the amount of Federal Taxes
or Combined State Taxes, as the case may be,
actually payable (or of the Federal Tax or Combined State Tax
refund that would have been receivable) by the Aetna Consolidated Group.
(b) If, subsequent to the payment by Aetna to Spinco of any amount
pursuant to (or in accordance with the principles of) Section 3.06(a), there
shall be (i) a Final Determination that results in a disallowance or a reduction
of the Tax Asset so carried back or (ii) a reduction in the amount of the tax
benefit Effectively Realized by the Aetna Consolidated Group from such Tax Asset
as a result of the use by the Aetna Consolidated Group of a Tax Asset of the
Acquired Group (PROVIDED that, for purposes of clause (ii), to the extent that
the sum of the Tax Assets of the Acquired Group available to be used in the
Pre-Distribution Tax Period to which carryback is made and the Tax Assets of the
Health Group available to be used in such Pre-Distribution Tax Period exceeds
the Tax Assets permitted to be used by the Aetna Consolidated Group with respect
to such Pre-Distribution Tax Period, the same proportion of the Tax Assets of
the Acquired Group and of the Health Group shall be used, unless Aetna and
Spinco Jointly Decide otherwise), Spinco shall repay to Aetna, within three
calendar days of such event described in clause (i) or (ii) (an "EVENT" or,
collectively the "EVENTS"), any amount that would not have been payable to
Spinco pursuant to (or in accordance with the principles of) Section 3.06(a) had
the amount of the tax benefit been determined in light of the Events. In
addition, Spinco shall hold each member of the Acquired Group harmless from any
penalty or interest payable by any member of the Acquired Group as a result of
any such Events. Any such amount shall be paid by Spinco within three calendar
days of the payment by the Acquired Group of any such penalty or interest.
(c) Any refunds or credits of Tax received or otherwise Effectively
Realized by a member of the Acquired Group or the Health Group, as the case may
be, relating to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period, to the extent reflecting a Tax
saving attributable to any item of income, loss, credit, deduction or other Tax
attribute of any member of the Health Group or the Acquired Group, respectively,
shall be paid by such member of the Acquired Group or the Health Group,
respectively, to Spinco or Aetna, respectively, within three calendar days of
the receipt or other Effective Realization of such tax saving; PROVIDED that (i)
no such payment shall be required to the extent such refunds or credits are
attributable to (A) a Tax Asset of the Health Group or the Acquired Group,
respectively, for which payment has previously been made by the Acquired Group
or the Health Group, respectively, pursuant to (or in accordance with the
principles of) Section 3.06(a), this Section 3.06(c) or any other applicable
provision of this Agreement, or (B) an adjustment for which payment in respect
thereof has previously been made pursuant to (or in accordance with the
principles of) Section 3.05 or any other applicable provision of this Agreement,
and (ii) any refunds shall be paid net of any Tax liability to an
entity resulting from such entity's receipt of such refund from the Taxing
Authority.
Section 3.07. ADDITIONAL MATTERS. To the extent that any Parent Affiliate
or any Spinco Affiliate receives interest from a Taxing Authority relating to an
adjustment made in a Federal Tax Return or a Combined State Tax return of the
Aetna Consolidated Group, any obligations of Parent or Spinco, respectively,
under Section 3.05 or Section 3.06 arising from such adjustment shall be reduced
by any Tax incurred by the Parent Affiliate or the Spinco Affiliate,
respectively, on the receipt of such interest.
ARTICLE 4
Certain Covenants and Employee Benefits Matters
Section 4.01. SPINCO COVENANTS TO AETNA. (a) Spinco covenants to Aetna
that, during the period from the date on which the Merger Agreement was signed
through the Distribution Date, Aetna will not have caused the Acquired Group to
take a position on a material Federal Tax matter with respect to such period,
which position Aetna does not believe, at the time such position is taken,
should be treated as being supported by substantial authority (within the
meaning of the Code).
(b) Spinco covenants to Aetna that at no time prior to the Distribution
Date will Spinco or any Spinco Affiliate have filed a Return of a Consolidated
Group of which it is the parent and which includes any Parent Affiliate (except
for a Consolidated Group filing a Return for a Combined New York-Illinois Tax
that is the tax payable to the State of Illinois).
(c) Spinco covenants to Aetna that, during the period from the date on
which the Merger Agreement was signed through the Distribution Date, it shall
not adjust the Tax accounts of Aetna, Aetna Life Insurance and Annuity Company,
Aetna International, Inc. or certain Malaysian subsidiaries of Aetna
International, Inc., except in each case to the extent necessary to reflect the
accrual of current Tax liabilities and the making of payments of estimated Tax
installments.
Section 4.02. COVENANT REGARDING AMENDMENT OF RETURNS. Each member of
the Acquired Group covenants to the members of the Health Group that Aetna
shall not amend any Return of the Aetna Consolidated Group filed prior to the
Distribution Date, or change any tax election or any tax accounting method
reflected on any such Return, which amendment or change would result in a
material increase in the tax liability (or a material reduction of any Tax
Asset) of the Health Group with
respect to any Pre-Distribution Tax Period, except in each case to the extent
(i) permitted by Article 8 of this Agreement, (ii) required by any applicable
Final Determination, or (iii) agreed to by Spinco.
Section 4.03. CERTAIN DEDUCTIONS RELATING TO EMPLOYEE BENEFITS MATTERS.
(a) For purposes of this Agreement, Spinco shall be entitled to the economic
benefit of any Federal Tax or other Tax deductions, for any Tax period
(including without limitation any Post-Distribution Tax Period), that are
(i) attributable to the cancellation under Section 2.04(b)(i) of the Employee
Benefits Agreement of options with respect to the Aetna Common Stock,
(ii) attributable to the exercise following the Distribution Date of any
option with respect to the common stock of Spinco, which option shall have
been converted from an option with respect to the Aetna Common Stock pursuant
to Section 2.04(b)(ii) of the Employee Benefits Agreement, (iii) attributable
to any payments of cash under Section 2.04(b)(ii) of the Employee Benefits
Agreement, (iv) in connection with AUSHC Bonus Liabilities (as defined in
Section 2.04(c) of the Employee Benefits Agreement), (v) in connection with
Retained Supplemental Liabilities (as defined in Section 3.02(a)(ii) of the
Employee Benefits Agreement), (vi) in connection with AUSHC Deferred
Compensation Liabilities (as defined in Section 3.02(b)(ii) of the Employee
Benefits Agreement), (vii) in connection with Retained Retiree Health and
Life Liabilities (as defined in Section 4.02(a) of the Employee Benefits
Agreement), (viii) in connection with the AUSHC WCP Liabilities (as defined
in Section 4.06(b) of the Employee Benefits Agreement), (ix) in connection
with AUSHC Phantom Liabilities (as defined in Section 4.11(b) of the Employee
Benefits Agreement), (x) in connection with Director Liabilities (within the
meaning of Article 5 of the Employee Benefits Agreement), (xi) in connection
with AUSHC International Liabilities (within the meaning of Section 5.02 of
the Employee Benefits Agreement), or (xii) in connection with such other
AUSHC Retained Liabilities (as defined in the Employee Benefits Agreement)
(excluding any AI Assumed Liabilities as defined in the Employee Benefits
Agreement) as are paid or otherwise satisfied by Spinco or another Spinco
Affiliate (any deduction described in this first sentence of Section 4.03(a)
constituting a "SPECIFIED DEDUCTION"). Without limiting the generality of the
preceding sentence, (i) Spinco (or another Spinco Affiliate designated by
Spinco) shall be entitled to claim any Specified Deduction, and (ii) for any
Specified Deduction that is not claimed pursuant to clause (i) of this
sentence, Spinco and Aetna shall cooperate in good faith to (A) determine
whether, and the manner in which, such Specified Deduction shall be claimed
on the Tax return of Spinco, another Spinco Affiliate, Aetna or another
Parent Affiliate (or on the Tax return of a Consolidated Group of which any
of such corporations is a member) for any applicable Tax period, and
(B) establish the entitlement to such Specified Deduction; PROVIDED that
nothing in clause (ii) of this sentence shall require Aetna, any other Parent
Affiliate, Spinco, any other Spinco Affiliate or a Consolidated Group of
which any of such
corporations is a member, to take any position that is not supported by
substantial authority (within the meaning of the Code).
(b) To the extent that a Specified Deduction is (i) claimed by Spinco or
any other Spinco Affiliate on its separate Tax return (or on the Tax return of a
Consolidated Group of which such corporation is a member and of which no Parent
Affiliate is a member) for any Tax period, and (ii) disallowed because a Taxing
Authority makes a Final Determination that Aetna or any other Parent Affiliate
should have claimed such Specified Deduction with respect to any Tax period,
Aetna shall pay to Spinco an amount equal to the resulting actual Tax benefit
Effectively Realized by any Parent Affiliate (or any member, except for any
Spinco Affiliate, of a Consolidated Group of which any Parent Affiliate is a
member), together with the related After-Tax Amount, within three calendar days
of the Effective Realization thereof.
(c) To the extent that a Specified Deduction is claimed by Aetna or any
other Parent Affiliate on its separate Tax return (or on the Tax return of a
Consolidated Group of which such corporation is a member) for any Tax period,
Aetna shall pay to Spinco an amount equal to the resulting actual Tax benefit
Effectively Realized by any Parent Affiliate (or any member, except for any
Spinco Affiliate, of a Consolidated Group of which any Parent Affiliate is a
member), together with the related After-Tax Amount, within three calendar days
of the date on which the Tax return reflecting such Specified Deduction is
filed. If, subsequent to the payment by Aetna to Spinco of any amount pursuant
to this Section 4.03(c), there shall be a Final Determination that results in a
disallowance or a reduction of such Specified Deduction, Spinco shall pay to
Aetna, within three calendar days of such disallowance, any amount that would
not have been payable to Spinco pursuant to this Section 4.03(c) had such
disallowance been known. In addition, Spinco shall hold each Parent Affiliate
harmless from any penalty or interest payable by such Parent Affiliate as a
result of such disallowance.
Section 4.04. CERTAIN TRANSACTIONS EXPENSES. For purposes of this
Agreement, Spinco shall be entitled to the economic benefit of any Federal Tax
or other Tax deductions, for any Tax period (including any Post-Distribution Tax
Period), that are attributable to any transaction expenses that are paid by
Aetna Inc. and economically borne by Spinco or any Spinco Affiliate. This
Section 4.04 shall be implemented by applying the provisions of Section 4.03
MUTATIS MUTANDIS with respect to transaction expenses described in the preceding
sentence.
Section 4.05. CERTAIN OTHER MATTERS. The parties agree as to the matters
set forth on (i) Schedule 4.05A in connection with certain dispositions effected
by Aetna International, Inc. or (ii) Schedule 4.05B.
ARTICLE 5
Indemnities
Section 5.01. INDEMNIFICATION OF PARENT AFFILIATES BY SPINCO AFFILIATES.
Spinco and each Spinco Affiliate (except for the Travelers Companies) shall
jointly and severally indemnify Aetna and each Parent Affiliate against and hold
them harmless from the following, without duplication:
(a) any Health Group Tax Liability, except for any liability (or portion
thereof) that is described in Section 5.02(d);
(b) any liability for Taxes attributable to any Spinco Affiliate
(PROVIDED that, for the purposes of the foregoing portion of this
Section 5.01(b), Taxes shall refer only to such taxes as are described in
clause (i) or clause (iii) of the definition of such term in Section 1.01(a))
(including without limitation (i) any Tax liability of Spinco or of any
Spinco Affiliate that was a direct or indirect Subsidiary of Spinco
immediately after Aetna's acquisition in 1996 of Spinco, which Tax liability
relates to tax periods ending on the date of, or prior to, such acquisition,
and (ii) any liability with respect to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period of a
member of the Health Group for which a Taxing Authority holds any member of
the Acquired Group liable solely by reason (taking into account for this
purpose the principles of this Agreement) of Treasury Regulations
Section 1.1502-6 or comparable provisions of United States state or local or
foreign law), but excluding any liability (or portion thereof) that is
described in Section 5.02(d);
(c) the net amount (if a liability) of (i) the Federal Tax liabilities
paid and/or interest paid (which interest shall be adjusted downwards for the
Federal Tax deductions to a Parent Affiliate resulting from its payment using
the highest rate of tax specified in Section 11(b) of the Code) to the Internal
Revenue Service by, and (ii) the refunds of Federal Tax and/or interest (which
interest shall be adjusted downwards for the Federal Tax incurred by a Parent
Affiliate on the receipt of such interest using the highest rate of tax
specified in Section 11(b) of the Code) received from the Internal Revenue
Service by, in the case of each of clauses (i) and (ii) the Parent Affiliates
with respect to the specific Federal Tax items that are set forth on Schedule
5.01 and that relate solely to Pre-1995 Tax Periods (each such Federal Tax item
constituting a "COVERED TAX ITEM"); PROVIDED that, except for the funding
arrangements under Section 5.03(b), no indemnification obligation shall arise
under this Section 5.01(c) until the date (the "COVERED ITEMS PAYMENT DATE")
that is 10 calendar days after the date (the "COVERED ITEMS DETERMINATION DATE")
on which, for Federal Tax purposes, a Final Determination shall be in place for
each of the Covered Tax Items;
(d) any Tax liability of any member of the Health Group resulting from the
existence of any excess loss account or deferred intercompany gain immediately
before the Distribution (which excess loss account or deferred intercompany gain
is triggered by the Distribution under the Treasury regulations promulgated
under Section 1502 of the Code), except for any liability (or portion thereof)
that is described in Section 5.02(d); PROVIDED that, for the purposes of this
Section 5.01(d), Tax shall refer only to such taxes as are described in clause
(i) or clause (iii) of the definition of such term in Section 1.01(a);
(e) any Tax liability of any member of the Acquired Group resulting from
the existence of any excess loss account or deferred intercompany gain
immediately before the Distribution (which excess loss account or deferred
intercompany gain (i) is triggered by the Distribution or the Merger under the
Treasury regulations promulgated under Section 1502 of the Code and (ii) did not
arise, and was not increased, solely by reason of such portions of the Spin-Off
as precede the Distribution), except (A) to the extent that the aggregate amount
of the Tax liabilities described in this Section 5.01(e), without taking into
account the following clause (B), does not exceed US$10 million, and (B) for any
liability (or portion thereof) that is described in Section 5.02(d); PROVIDED
that, for the purposes of this Section 5.01(e), Tax shall refer only to such
taxes as are described in clause (i) or clause (iii) of the definition of such
term in Section 1.01(a);
(f) any Tax indemnity payment required to be made by any Parent Affiliate
or any Spinco Affiliate under the Prior Deal Agreements or the AUSHC Agreements;
(g) any Tax liability relating to (or resulting from the treatment of) the
transactions described in the Travelers Agreements, the Lincoln Agreements, the
AmRe Agreements or the Miscellaneous Agreements;
(h) any Tax liability relating to (or resulting from the treatment of) the
assets acquired pursuant to, or the transactions described in, the AUSHC
Agreements, the NYLCare Agreements or the Prudential Agreements;
(i) any Tax liability relating to (or resulting from the treatment of)
the Spin-Off, except for any liability (or portion thereof) that is described
in Section 5.02(d); PROVIDED that this Section 5.01 (i) shall not describe
(A) any Tax liability resulting from the existence of any excess loss account
or deferred intercompany gain immediately before the Distribution (except for
Tax liability of any member of the Acquired Group resulting from the
existence of any excess loss account or deferred intercompany gain
immediately before the Distribution, to the extent that such excess loss
account or deferred intercompany gain (x) is triggered by the Distribution or
the Merger under the Treasury Regulations promulgated under Section 1502 of
the Code and (y) arose, or was increased, solely by reason of such portions
of the Spin-Off as precede the Distribution; PROVIDED that for purposes of
such exception Tax shall refer only to such taxes as are described in clause
(i) or clause (iii) of the definition of such term in Section 1.01(a)), or
(B) such transfer, documentary, sales, use, stamp and registration Taxes as
shall be borne by Aetna under Section 8.08(d) of the Distribution Agreement;
(j) any liability or damage resulting from a breach by Spinco or any other
Spinco Affiliate of any representation or covenant made by such entity in, or of
any other provision of, this Agreement; and
(k) all liabilities, costs, expenses (including without limitation
reasonable expenses of investigation and attorneys' fees and expenses), losses,
damages, assessments, settlements or judgments arising out of or incident to the
imposition, assessment or assertion of any liability or damage described in (a),
(b), (c), (d), (e), (f), (g), (h), (i) or (j), including without limitation
those incurred in the contest in good faith in appropriate proceedings relating
to the imposition, assessment or assertion of any such liability or damage.
Section 5.02. INDEMNIFICATION OF SPINCO AFFILIATES BY PARENT AFFILIATES.
Aetna and each Parent Affiliate shall jointly and severally indemnify Spinco and
each Spinco Affiliate against and hold them harmless from the following, without
duplication:
(a) any Federal Tax or Combined State Tax liability of the Aetna
Consolidated Group with respect to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period, to the extent
that such liability (or a portion thereof) is neither a Health Group Tax
Liability nor any other item that is described in Section 5.01;
(b) any liability for Taxes attributable to any Parent Affiliate
(PROVIDED that, for the purposes of the foregoing portion of this
Section 5.02(b), Taxes shall refer only to such taxes as are described in
clause (i) or clause (iii) of the definition of such term in
Section 1.01(a)), including without limitation any liability with respect to
a Pre-Distribution Tax Period of a member of the Acquired Group for which a
Taxing Authority holds any member of the Health Group liable solely by reason
(taking into account for this purpose the principles of this Agreement) of
Treasury Regulations Section 1.1502-6 or comparable provisions of United
States state or local or foreign law, but excluding any liability (or portion
thereof) that is described in Section 5.01(c), Section 5.01(e),
Section 5.01(f), Section 5.01(g), Section 5.01(h), Section 5.01(i) or
Section 5.01(j);
(c) any Tax indemnity payment required to be made by any Parent Affiliate
or any Spinco Affiliate under the Aetna International Disposition Agreements, or
any Tax liability relating to (or resulting from the treatment of) the
transactions described in the Aetna International Disposition Agreements;
(d) any liability or damage resulting from a breach, after the
Distribution Date, by Aetna or any other Parent Affiliate of any covenant made
by such entity in, or of any other provision of, this Agreement; and
(e) all liabilities, costs, expenses (including without limitation
reasonable expenses of investigation and attorneys' fees and expenses), losses,
damages, assessments, settlements or judgments arising out of or incident to the
imposition, assessment or assertion of any liability or damage described in (a),
(b), (c) or (d), including without limitation those incurred in the contest in
good faith in appropriate proceedings relating to the imposition, assessment or
assertion of any such liability or damage.
Section 5.03. TREATMENT OF INTERIM PAYMENTS AND REFUNDS WITH RESPECT
TO, AND CERTAIN OTHER MATTERS REGARDING, COVERED TAX ITEMS. (a) For purposes
of performing the calculation following the Covered Items Determination Date
of the net amount described in Section 5.01(c), any refund of Federal Tax
and/or interest (with the adjustment to the interest for Federal Tax effects
set forth in
clause (ii) of Section 5.01(c)) with respect to a Covered Tax Item, which refund
is described in clause (ii) of Section 5.01(c), shall offset on a
dollar-for-dollar basis any Federal Tax liability and/or interest (with the
adjustment to the interest for Federal Tax effects set forth in clause (i) of
Section 5.01(c)) with respect to any of the Covered Tax Items, which liability
or interest is described in clause (i) of Section 5.01(c), regardless of whether
such refund is received before, at the same time as, or after, the payment of
such liability or interest.
(b) Notwithstanding that no indemnification obligation shall arise under
Section 5.01(c) until the Covered Items Payment Date, Spinco or another Spinco
Affiliate shall (i) within the time limit specified by the Internal Revenue
Service for payment, fund any cash payments to the Internal Revenue Service of
tax with respect to any Covered Tax Item and/or of interest with respect to any
Covered Tax item (with the adjustment to the interest for Federal Tax effects
set forth in clause (i) of Section 5.01(c)), and (ii) be entitled to any refunds
received from the Internal Revenue Service of tax with respect to any Covered
Tax Item and/or of interest with respect to any Covered Tax Item (with the
adjustment to the interest for Federal Tax effects set forth in clause (ii) of
Section 5.01(c)). Any Parent Affiliate that receives a refund from the Internal
Revenue Service of tax and/or interest shall, within three calendar days of such
receipt, transfer to Spinco immediately available funds in an amount equal to
such tax and/or interest (with the adjustment to the interest for Federal Tax
effects set forth in clause (ii) of Section 5.01(c)).
(c) To the extent that Aetna and Spinco Jointly Decide that it is
appropriate for a Spinco Affiliate to claim the interest deductions reflected in
adjustments to the interest for Federal Tax effects set forth in clause (i) of
Section 5.01(c), such adjustments shall be reduced by such interest deductions
(absent a Final Determination to the contrary) for purposes of Section 5.01(c),
Section 5.03(a) and Section 5.03(b). If Aetna and Spinco each agrees, the
principles of this Section 5.03(c) shall be applied to any interest obligations,
where applicable.
Section 5.04. DISCHARGE OF INDEMNITY. Each party with indemnification
obligations under Section 5.01 or 5.02 (an "INDEMNITOR"), as the case may be,
shall discharge its obligations thereunder by paying the sum of the relevant
amount and the related After-Tax Amount, within three calendar days of demand
therefor, to the party that is indemnified under such provision (the
"INDEMNITEE"). After a Final Determination of an obligation for which an
Indemnitee is to be indemnified, the Indemnitee shall send a statement to the
Indemnitor showing the amount due under Section 5.01 or 5.02 and the related
After-Tax Amount. Calculation mechanics relating to appropriate items
described in Section 5.01 and 5.02 shall be in accordance with the principles
of this Agreement. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if an Indemnitor disputes
in good faith the fact or the amount of its obligation under Section 5.01 or
5.02, no
payment of the amount in dispute shall be required until any such good faith
dispute is resolved in accordance with Section 10.09 hereof; PROVIDED that
any amount not paid within three calendar days of demand therefor shall bear
interest as provided in Article 9.
Section 5.05. TREATMENT OF INDEMNIFICATION PAYMENTS. Any payments made by
any Spinco Affiliate to any Parent Affiliate under Section 5.01 shall be treated
as involving a deemed dividend by such Spinco Affiliate, which deemed dividend
shall be eliminated under the Treasury regulations promulgated under
Section 1502 of the Code. Any payments made by any Parent Affiliate to any
Spinco Affiliate under Section 5.02 shall be treated as a capital contribution.
Section 5.06. CERTAIN ENTITIES AS INDEMNITEES. (a) Amounts paid in
discharge of any indemnification obligation under Section 5.02 for which the
Indemnitee is (i) Aetna Services, Inc. or (ii) any entity that has no
successor and that is no longer in existence at the time of its entitlement
to indemnification, in the case of each of clauses (i) and (ii) shall be paid
to Spinco.
(b) Amounts paid in discharge of any indemnification obligation under
Section 5.01 for which the Indemnitee is an entity that has no successor and
that is no longer in existence at the time of its entitlement to indemnification
shall be paid to Aetna.
Section 5.07. NON-EXCLUSIVITY OF REMEDIES. The remedies provided for in
this Article 5 are not exclusive and shall not limit any rights or remedies
which may otherwise be available to any Indemnified Party at law or in equity.
Section 5.08. ENTITLEMENTS UNDER CERTAIN AGREEMENTS. (a) Spinco shall
be entitled to the excess of (i) any Tax indemnity payment received by any
Spinco Affiliate or any Parent Affiliate under the Prior Deal Agreements or
the AUSHC Agreements, over (ii) in the case of receipt by a Parent Affiliate,
any Tax liability incurred by such Parent Affiliate as a result of the
receipt of such Tax indemnity payment.
(b) Aetna shall be entitled to the excess of (i) any Tax indemnity payment
received by any Parent Affiliate or any Spinco Affiliate under the Aetna
International Disposition Agreements, over (ii) in the case of receipt by a
Spinco Affiliate, any Tax liability incurred by such Spinco Affiliate as a
result of the receipt of such Tax indemnity payment.
Section 5.09. CERTAIN TRANSFER TAXES. Notwithstanding anything in
Section 8.08(d) of the Distribution Agreement to the contrary, Spinco shall
bear and pay the excess, if any, of (i) the amount of all transfer,
documentation, sales, use, stamp and registration taxes and fees (including
any penalties and interest) (collectively, "TRANSFER TAXES") incurred in
connection with (A) the assignment, contribution, conveyance, transfer and
delivery to Aelan Inc. of all the assets and liabilities of the Aetna Global
Benefits Business that are owned by, or that are
obligations of, Aetna International, Inc. (including, without limitation, all of
the outstanding shares of capital stock of ALCBL) (the "AETNA GLOBAL BENEFITS
ASSETS/LIABILITIES"), and (B) the contribution by Aetna to the capital of Spinco
of all of the outstanding shares of capital stock of Aelan Inc., over (ii) the
amount of all Transfer Taxes that would have been incurred in connection with
(A) the contribution of the Aetna Global Benefits Assets/Liabilities to a newly
formed limited liability company ("NEW LLC"), and (B) the distribution to Aetna,
followed by the contribution by Aetna to the capital of Spinco, of the
membership interests in New LLC and all of the outstanding shares of capital
stock of Aelan Inc. Nothing in this Section 5.09 shall affect the responsibility
of Spinco, under Section 8.08(d) the Distribution Agreement, to bear and pay 50%
of the amount that is the lesser of the amount described in clause (i) of the
preceding sentence and the amount described in clause (ii) thereof.
ARTICLE 6
Subsidiaries
Section 6.01. PERFORMANCE. Parent and Aetna agree and acknowledge that
each of Parent and Aetna shall be responsible for the performance, and guarantee
the obligations, of each Parent Affiliate under this Agreement (including
without limitation any indemnification obligations under Article 5). Spinco
agrees and acknowledges that it shall be responsible for the performance, and
guarantee the obligations, of each other Spinco Affiliate (except for the
Travelers Companies and for any Person sold by any Spinco Affiliate or any
Parent Affiliate under the Prior Deal Agreements) under this Agreement
(including without limitation any indemnification obligations under Article 5).
ARTICLE 7
Access to Information and Cooperation
Section 7.01. CONSULTATION AND COOPERATION. Aetna and Spinco shall
consult and cooperate (and shall cause the Parent Affiliates or the Spinco
Affiliates, respectively, to cooperate) fully (or, in the case of Spinco
Affiliates that are Travelers Companies, to the extent contemplated in the
Travelers Agreements) at such time and to the extent reasonably requested by
Spinco or Aetna, respectively, in connection with all matters subject to this
Agreement. Such cooperation shall include without limitation:
(i) (A) except as set forth in Section 7.02, the retention and provision
on reasonable request of any and all information (including without limitation
all books, records, documentation or other information) pertaining to Tax
matters
relating to any of the Parent Affiliates or any of the Spinco Affiliates, (B)
any necessary explanations of information and (C) access to personnel, in the
case of each of clauses (A) through (C) until the expiration of the applicable
statute of limitation (giving effect to any extension or waiver thereof);
(ii) the execution, acknowledgment or delivery of any document that may be
necessary or helpful in connection with (A) any Return, (B) any Tax Proceeding
or investigation, or (C) the carrying out of a party's obligations under this
Agreement; and
(iii) the use of the parties' reasonable best efforts to obtain any
documentation from a governmental authority or a third party that may be
necessary or helpful in connection with the foregoing, including without
limitation pursuant to the Prior Deal Agreements, the AUSHC Agreement or the
Aetna International Disposition Agreements.
(b) The party that requests cooperation under Section 7.01(a) shall
reimburse the party that furnishes such cooperation and its Affiliates for
reasonable out-of-pocket expenses incurred by the latter party or its Affiliates
and paid to a third party in fulfilling such request, which expenses would not
have been incurred absent such request.
Section 7.02. CORPORATE RECORDS. Until the expiration of the applicable
statutes of limitation (giving effect to any extension or waiver thereof),
except as otherwise required by law or agreed to by Aetna and Spinco in writing,
each of the Parent Affiliates and the Spinco Affiliates shall continue to hold
the material documents, books, records, files or papers, or other material
information, pertaining to Tax matters (whether in hard copy or computer format)
that it possesses immediately prior to the Distribution Date. Notwithstanding
the foregoing, any Parent Affiliate or Spinco Affiliate may, consistent with its
documentation retention practices, destroy or otherwise dispose of any such
information at any time so long as, prior to such disposal, (i) such Parent
Affiliate or Spinco Affiliate shall provide not less than 90 calendar days'
prior written notice to Spinco or Aetna, respectively, specifying the
information proposed to be disposed of and the scheduled date for such disposal,
and (ii) if the recipient of such notice shall request in writing prior to the
scheduled date for such disposal that any of the information proposed to be
disposed of be delivered to the requesting party, the entity proposing such
disposal shall promptly arrange for the delivery of such portion of the
information as was requested (at the expense of the requesting party).
Section 7.03. PROVISION OF INFORMATION. (a) Aetna and Spinco shall keep
each other fully informed with respect to any material development relating
to the matters subject to this Agreement.
(b) Without limiting the generality of Section 7.03(a), Aetna shall
promptly provide Spinco with (i) any information document requests, any
notices
of proposed adjustments, any other material notices or any other information, in
each case received by Aetna from the Internal Revenue Service, any other Taxing
Authority or other third parties in connection with, or otherwise affecting, the
Tax liability of the Aetna Consolidated Group for a Pre-Distribution Tax Period,
and (ii) any other Tax information relating to the Aetna Consolidated Group that
is in the possession of, or otherwise available to, Aetna (or any other Parent
Affiliate) and that is reasonably requested by Spinco for a Pre-Distribution Tax
Period.
(c) Without limiting the generality of Section 7.03(a), Aetna and
Spinco shall advise each other with respect to any proposed Tax adjustments
relating to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period, which adjustments are the subject
of a Tax Proceeding or investigation and which may affect any Tax liability,
any Tax Asset or any Tax attribute of any Parent Affiliate or any Spinco
Affiliate (including without limitation basis in an asset or the amount of
earnings and profits).
Section 7.04. CONFIDENTIALITY. Each party shall hold and shall cause
its directors, officers, employees, counsel, accountants, agents,
consultants, advisors and other authorized representatives
("REPRESENTATIVES") to hold in strict confidence any Tax information
concerning one or more of the other parties hereto, unless (i) such
information is reflected on a Tax Return filed by (or on behalf of) one or
more of the parties or is relevant to a Tax Proceeding involving one or more
of the parties, (ii) such information is required to be disclosed in order to
comply with applicable Tax laws, (iii) the party with the confidentiality
commitment is compelled to disclose such information by judicial or
administrative process or, in the opinion of its counsel, by other
requirements of law, and/or (iv) such information can be shown to have been
(A) in the public domain through no fault of the party with the
confidentiality commitment, or (B) lawfully acquired after the Distribution
Date on a non-confidential basis from other sources. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, each party may disclose to its Representatives Tax information so
long as such Representatives are informed of the confidential nature of such
information and are directed to treat such information in a manner consistent
with this Section 7.04.
Section 7.05. PRESERVATION OF PRIVILEGE. (a) The parties hereto recognize
that some of the information, documents and records disclosed or exchanged
pursuant to or in furtherance of this Agreement may be confidential, work
product, or otherwise privileged under relevant laws and procedures, and each
party agrees to take all reasonable and necessary efforts to protect and
maintain, or to cause its Affiliates and its Representatives to protect and
maintain, any applicable claim to privilege, immunity, protection or
confidentiality in order to protect such information, documents and records from
improper disclosure or use. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing,
and to the maximum extent permitted by law, none of the parties may waive,
undermine or fail to defend any privilege or protection or take or fail to take
any action that (i) could result in the disclosure of any common-interest or
joint-defense materials to a Person that is neither a party to this Agreement
nor an Affiliate of any such party, or (ii) would have the effect of waiving or
undermining such privilege or protection, in the case
of each of clauses (i) and (ii) without the prior written consent of the
affected part(ies).
(b) Aetna and Spinco agree to cooperate to enter into such joint defense
agreements relating to Taxes as Aetna or Spinco may deem necessary or helpful to
achievement of the outcome described in Section 7.05(a).
Section 7.06. CERTAIN PAYROLL- AND EMPLOYEE-RELATED TAXES. (a) Aetna and
Spinco shall cooperate to Jointly Decide (i) the manner in which various
payroll-related Tax Returns (including without limitation withholding Tax
Returns) with respect to Pre-Distribution Tax Periods shall be filed, and (ii)
which of the Parent Affiliates and the Spinco Affiliates shall send such forms
(including without limitation Internal Revenue Service Form W-2 or any successor
form), or cause such forms to be sent, to employees as are required under
applicable Tax Laws.
(b) Aetna and Spinco shall cooperate to Jointly Decide (i) the manner in
which various information reporting Tax Returns, with respect to any Tax period
ending on or before December 31, 2001 shall be prepared, mailed to recipients,
and filed with the Internal Revenue Service (or other applicable Taxing
Authority), (ii) which of the Parent Affiliates and the Spinco Affiliates shall
send such forms, or cause such forms to be sent, to recipients and to the
Internal Revenue Service (or other applicable Taxing Authority), and (iii) an
approach for sharing the costs of preparing and mailing such Tax Returns (unless
the sharing of such costs is addressed by another Distribution Document). Aetna
and Spinco shall pay such portion of the costs attributable to the activities
described in the preceding sentence as relates to the Parent Affiliates or the
Spinco Affiliates, respectively.
ARTICLE 8
Tax Proceedings and Consent
Section 8.01. CONTROL OVER TAX PROCEEDINGS. (a) Except to the extent
otherwise provided in Section 8.03, Aetna shall have control over Tax matters
relating to any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding of
the Aetna Consolidated Group (i) with respect to a Post-1994 Tax Period in the
case of a Federal Tax or (ii) with respect to a Pre-Distribution Tax Period in
the case of a Combined State Tax, in each case which Tax matters predominantly
affect the Acquired Group. Except to the extent otherwise provided in
Section 8.03, Aetna shall have discretion regarding decisions to be made, or
the nature of any action to be taken, with respect to any matter described in
the preceding sentence. Except to the extent otherwise provided in
Section 8.03, Spinco shall have control over (i) Tax matters relating to any
Taxing Authority Proceeding or
Contract-Based Tax Proceeding of the Aetna Consolidated Group with respect to a
Pre-1995 Tax Period in the case of a Federal Tax, (ii) Tax matters relating to
any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding of the Aetna
Consolidated Group with respect to a Post-1994 Tax Period, which Tax matters in
this clause (ii) predominantly affect the Health Group, and (iii) Tax matters
relating to any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding of
the Aetna Consolidated Group with respect to a Pre-1995 Tax Period in the case
of a Combined State Tax, which Tax matters in this clause (iii) predominantly
affect the Health Group. Except to the extent otherwise provided in
Section 8.03, Spinco shall have discretion regarding decisions to be made, or
the nature of any action to be taken, with respect to any matter described in
the preceding sentence. In the case of a Federal Tax, the Covered Tax Items
shall be treated as predominantly relating to the Health Group for purposes
of this Agreement. Specified Deductions claimed in a Pre-Distribution Tax
Period shall be treated as predominantly relating to the Health Group for
purposes of this Agreement.
(b) To the extent that (i) two or more provisions of Section 8.01(a) would
otherwise apply to a Tax matter in a conflicting manner, or the control of a Tax
matter that is material to the tax liability of the Aetna Consolidated Group for
a Pre-Distribution Tax Period is not addressed by Section 8.01(a), and (ii) the
control of such Tax matter is not addressed by any other provision of this
Agreement, Aetna and Spinco shall Jointly Decide the handling of the Tax matter
in connection with any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax
Proceeding. Notwithstanding anything in Section 8.01(a) to the contrary, Aetna
and Spinco shall Jointly Decide, among other things, whether any extensions or
waivers of material statutes of limitation with respect to a Pre-Distribution
Tax Period shall be executed by the Aetna Consolidated Group.
(c) Without limiting the generality of the third and fourth sentences of
Section 8.01(a), control by Spinco of a Tax matter shall confer upon Spinco (i)
the right and obligation to respond to any information document requests from a
Taxing Authority relating to such Tax matter, (ii) the right to arrange for
Aetna to execute a power of attorney, or other similar document, entitling
Spinco to have direct discussions with a Taxing Authority on such Tax matter to
the extent required for Spinco to fully enforce its rights under this Agreement,
(iii) the right, but not the obligation, to participate (including without
limitation through the retention, at its own expense, of counsel of its own
choosing) in any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding
regarding such Tax matter (including without limitation in any discussions with
a Taxing Authority regarding compromise or settlement of such Tax matter), (iv)
the right, but not the obligation, upon notice to Aetna, to assume the defense
of the portion of the Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax
Proceeding that relates to such Tax matter, and (v) except to the extent
otherwise provided in Section 8.03,
the right to agree to or decline the settlement of such Tax matter. If Spinco
assumes the defense of any Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax
Proceeding, Aetna shall have the right, but not the obligation, to participate
(including without limitation through the retention, at its own expense, of
counsel of its own choosing) in such Tax Proceeding.
(d) Except as otherwise provided in this Article 8, Aetna shall bear all
fees, costs and expenses in connection with the portions of a Taxing Authority
Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding that are attributable to Tax matters
controlled by Aetna. Except as otherwise provided in this Article 8, Spinco
shall bear all fees, costs and expenses in connection with the portions of a
Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding that are
attributable to Tax matters controlled by Spinco. Aetna and Spinco shall each
bear 50% of all fees, costs and expenses in connection with the portions of a
Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Tax Proceeding that are
attributable to Tax matters Jointly Decided by Aetna and Spinco. Notwithstanding
any other provision in this Section 8.01(d), in the event that Aetna or Spinco,
whichever party (if either) under this Section 8.01 has control over a Federal
Tax matter, notifies the other party that it is interested in litigating a
Taxing Authority Proceeding with respect to such Tax matter in the Court of
Federal Claims or a district court, such controlling party shall satisfy the
requirement that Tax be paid to the Internal Revenue Service before such
controlling party pursues such Taxing Authority Proceeding in the Court of
Federal Claims or such district court.
Section 8.02. NOTIFICATION OF CLAIMS. The Indemnitee agrees to give
prompt notice to the Indemnitor of the assertion of any claim, or the
commencement of any suit, action or proceeding in respect of which indemnity
may be sought under Section 5.01 or 5.02.
Section 8.03. SETTLEMENT OF TAX PROCEEDINGS. (a) Notwithstanding
anything in this Agreement to the contrary, no settlement of any Taxing
Authority Proceeding or any Contract-Based Tax Proceeding, in each case
relating to any matter that would cause a payment obligation under
Section 5.01 or Section 5.02, whichever is applicable, shall be accepted or
entered into by or on behalf of an Indemnitee entitled to indemnification
under Section 5.01 or Section 5.02, unless the applicable Indemnitor consents
thereto in writing (which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld). For
purposes of the preceding sentence, any withholding by an Indemnitor of
consent shall be conclusively treated as being reasonable if the payment
obligation under Section 5.01 or Section 5.02, as the case may be, that would
result from the settlement for the acceptance of which consent is being
sought exceeds US$2.5 million.
(b) The Indemnitor shall consult with the Indemnitee regarding the
settlement of any material Taxing Authority Proceeding or Contract-Based Taxing
Proceeding and shall consider the Indemnitee's views in good faith; PROVIDED
that
such consultation and consideration shall not affect the determination of
whether the Indemnitor has acted reasonably. If consent is unreasonably withheld
by an Indemnitor with respect to a payment obligation of US$2.5 million or less,
all expenses that relate to the contest of such matter and that are incurred
following such withholding of consent shall be borne by the Indemnitor.
(c) Subject to Section 8.03(a), if the Indemnitor does not respond to the
Indemnitee's written request for consent within 10 calendar days of receipt of
such request, the Indemnitor shall be deemed to have consented to the
settlement.
ARTICLE 9
Payments
Section 9.01. PROCEDURE FOR MAKING PAYMENTS. All payments to be made
pursuant to this Agreement shall be made in immediately available funds. Except
as otherwise provided in this Agreement, all payments required to be made
pursuant to this Agreement shall be due three calendar days after the receipt of
notice of such payment or, where no notice is required, five calendar days after
(i) the fixing of liability, (ii) the Effective Realization of a tax saving or
tax benefit, (iii) the receipt of a refund, or (iv) the resolution of a dispute,
as the case may be. Payments shall be deemed made when received. Except as
otherwise provided in this Agreement, any payment that is not made when due
shall bear interest at the Intercompany Interest Rate for each day until paid.
ARTICLE 10
Miscellaneous
Section 10.01. AUTHORIZATION. Each of the parties to this Agreement
hereby represents and warrants that (i) it has the power and authority to
execute, deliver and perform this Agreement, (ii) this Agreement has been duly
authorized by all necessary corporate action on the part of such party, (iii)
this Agreement constitutes a legal, valid and binding obligation of such party,
and (iv) the execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement by such party
does not contravene or conflict with any provision or law or of its charter or
bylaws or any agreement, instrument or order binding on such party.
Section 10.02. NOTICES. All notices, requests, demands, claims and other
communications to any party hereunder shall be in writing (including facsimile
or similar writing) and shall be deemed given when received addressed as
follows:
If to Aetna, to:
Lion Connecticut Holdings Inc.
000 Xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx 00000-0000
Attention: Xxxxxxxx Xxxxxx
General Counsel
Fax: 000-000-0000
Xxxxxx Xxxx
Vice President
Fax: 000-000-0000
With copies to:
ING America Insurance Holdings, Inc.
in c/o ING North America Insurance Corp.
0000 Xxxxxx Xxxxx Xxxx, XX
Xxxxxxx, Xxxxxxx 00000-0000
Attention: Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxxxxx
Executive Vice President &
Chief Financial Officer
Fax: 000-000-0000
B. Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Senior Vice President &
Chief Counsel
Fax: 000-000-0000
Xxxx X. Xxxxx
Senior Vice President
Fax: 000-000-0000
and
Xxxxxxxx & Xxxxxxxx
000 Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxx Xxxx, Xxx Xxxx 00000
Attention: Xxxxxx X. Xxxxxxx, Esq.
Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxxxx, Esq.
Fax: 000-000-0000
If to Spinco, to:
Aetna Inc.
000 Xxxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxxxxx 00000-0000
Attention: L. Xxxxxx Xxxx, Xx.
General Counsel
Fax: 000-000-0000
Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxx
Corporate Secretary
Fax: 000-000-0000
Xxxxx X. Xxxxxx
Vice President, Tax
Fax: 000-000-0000
With a copy to:
Xxxxx Xxxx & Xxxxxxxx
000 Xxxxxxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxx Xxxx, Xxx Xxxx 00000
Attention: Xxxxx X. Xxxxx, Esq.
Xxxxx X. Xxxxxx, Esq.
Fax: 000-000-0000
If to Parent, to:
ING America Insurance Holdings, Inc.
in c/o ING North America Insurance Corp.
0000 Xxxxxx Xxxxx Xxxx, XX
Xxxxxxx, Xxxxxxx 00000-0000
Attention: Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxxxxx
Executive Vice President &
Chief Financial Officer
Fax: 000-000-0000
B. Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Senior Vice President &
Chief Counsel
Fax: 000-000-0000
Xxxx X. Xxxxx
Senior Vice President
Fax: 000-000-0000
With copies to:
Xxxxxxxxxxxxxx 0000, 1077 ZZ Amsterdam
X.X. Xxx 000
0000 Xx. Xxxxxxxxx, xxx Xxxxxxxxxxx
Attention: Xxxx Xxxxxxx
Executive Board Member
Fax: x00-00-000-0000
Diederik van Wassenaer
General Counsel
Fax: x00-00-000-0000
and
Xxxxxxxx & Xxxxxxxx
000 Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxx Xxxx, Xxx Xxxx 00000
Attention: Xxxxxx X. Xxxxxxx, Esq.
Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxxxx, Esq.
Fax: 000-000-0000
Any party may, by written notice so delivered to the other parties, change
the address to which delivery of any notice shall thereafter be made.
Section 10.03. AMENDMENTS; NO WAIVERS. (a) Any provision of this
Agreement may be amended or waived if, but only if, such amendment or waiver
is (i) in writing, and (ii) signed, in the case of an amendment, by each
party to this Agreement or, in the case of a waiver, by each party against
whom the waiver is to be effective. Parent, Aetna and the other Parent
Affiliates shall have the right, in connection with any of the matters
covered by this Agreement or other Tax matters, to make additional
arrangements among themselves without the approval of Spinco, so long as the
rights of the Spinco Affiliates under this Agreement are not adversely
affected by such additional arrangements. Spinco and the other Spinco
Affiliates shall have the right, in connection with any of the matters
covered by this Agreement or other Tax matters, to make additional
arrangements among themselves without the approval of Parent or Aetna, so
long as the rights of Parent and the Parent Affiliates under this Agreement
are not adversely affected by such additional arrangements.
(b) No failure or delay by any party in exercising any right, power or
privilege hereunder shall operate as a waiver thereof, nor shall any single or
partial exercise thereof preclude any other or further exercise thereof or the
exercise of any other right, power or privilege. The rights and remedies herein
provided shall be cumulative and not exclusive of any rights or remedies
provided by law.
Section 10.04. EXPENSES. Except as specifically otherwise provided in
this Agreement or any other Distribution Document, all fees, costs and expenses
incurred in connection with this Agreement shall be paid by the party incurring
such fees, costs or expenses. Without limiting the generality of the preceding
sentence, no Spinco Affiliate shall be obligated to make any payment to Aetna
for preparing Returns of the Aetna Consolidated Group or for acting, in
accordance with Section 2.02 of this Agreement, as agent, coordinator and
administrator of the members of the Health Group.
Section 10.05. SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS; NO THIRD PARTY BENEFICIARIES. The
provisions of this Agreement shall be binding upon and inure only to the benefit
of the parties hereto, the Parent Affiliates and the Spinco Affiliates (and
their respective successors and assigns, whether by merger, acquisition of
assets or otherwise, and including without limitation any successor succeeding
to the tax attributes of such corporation under applicable law); PROVIDED that,
except as set forth in this Agreement, no party may assign, delegate or
otherwise transfer any of its rights or obligations under this Agreement without
the prior written consent of each of the other parties hereto. This Agreement is
not intended to benefit any person other than (i) the parties hereto and their
respective successors and assigns and (ii) the other Parent Affiliates and the
other Spinco Affiliates and their respective successors and assigns; and no such
other person shall be a third party beneficiary of this Agreement.
Section 10.06. GOVERNING LAW. This Agreement shall be construed in
accordance with and governed by the law of the State of Delaware, without regard
to the conflicts of law rules thereof.
Section 10.07. COUNTERPARTS; EFFECTIVENESS. This Agreement may be signed
in any number of counterparts, each of which shall be an original, with the same
effect as if the signatures thereto and hereto were upon the same instrument.
This Agreement shall become effective upon the consummation of the Distribution;
PROVIDED that each party hereto shall have received, prior to such consummation,
from each of the other parties hereto a counterpart hereof signed by such other
party.
Section 10.08. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Agreement, the Merger Agreement,
the Confidentiality Agreement and the other Distribution Documents constitute
the entire understanding of the parties with respect to the subject matter
hereof and thereof and supersede all prior agreements, understandings and
negotiations, both written and oral, between the parties with respect to the
subject matter hereof and thereof. No representation, inducement, promise,
understanding, condition or warranty not set forth herein or in the other
Distribution Documents has been made or relied upon by any party hereto. To the
extent that the provisions of this Agreement are inconsistent with the
provisions relating to Taxes of any other Distribution Document, the provisions
of this Agreement shall prevail.
Section 10.09. DISPUTE RESOLUTION. If the parties hereto are unable to
resolve any disagreement or dispute relating to this Agreement within 10
calendar days after senior Tax officials of the parties have conferred,
consulted and in good faith attempted to resolve such disagreement or dispute
(which conference, consultation or attempt shall not be withheld), such
disagreement or dispute shall be resolved by an accounting firm or law firm,
in each case which firm is nationally recognized as expert in tax matters and
is mutually acceptable to the parties hereto (a "REFEREE"). A Referee so
chosen shall resolve any such disagreement pursuant to such procedures as it
may deem advisable. Any such resolution shall be binding on the parties to
this Agreement without further recourse. In resolving a disagreement or
dispute, the Referee shall take into account the provisions (including
without limitation Section 8.01 and Section 8.03) and principles of this
Agreement. The costs of any Referee shall be allocated between Aetna and
Spinco as determined by such Referee in a manner that such Referee deems
reasonable (taking into account, among other things, the circumstances of the
dispute, the conduct of the parties and the results of the dispute).
Section 10.10. JURISDICTION. Any Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding may be
brought in the United States District Court for the District of Delaware, and
each of the parties hereby consents to the jurisdiction of such courts (and of
the appropriate appellate courts therefrom) in any Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding
and irrevocably waives, to the fullest extent permitted by law, any objection it
may now or hereafter have (i) to the laying of the venue of any Spinco-Aetna Tax
Proceeding in any such court, or (ii) that any Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding which
is brought in any such court has been brought in an inconvenient forum. Process
in any Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding may be served on any party anywhere in the
world, whether within or without the jurisdiction of any such court. Without
limiting the foregoing, each party agrees that service of process on such party
as provided in Section 10.01 shall be deemed effective service of process on
such party in connection with any Spinco-Aetna Tax Proceeding.
Section 10.11. FURTHER ASSURANCES. Aetna, Parent and Spinco shall
execute, acknowledge and deliver (or cause to be executed, acknowledged and
delivered) such documents, and take such other action, as may be necessary or
advisable to carry out their obligations under this Agreement and under any
document delivered pursuant hereto.
Section 10.12. SEVERABILITY. If any one or more provisions of this
Agreement (or the application of any such provisions to any party or any
circumstances) should be held to be invalid, illegal or unenforceable in any
respect, the validity, legality and enforceability of the remaining provisions
contained in this Agreement (and/or the application of the invalid, illegal or
unenforceable provisions other than to such party or such circumstances) shall
not in any way be affected or impaired thereby. The parties shall endeavor in
good faith negotiations to replace the invalid, illegal or unenforceable
provisions so that the replacement provisions shall be valid, legal and
enforceable and shall have an economic effect which comes as close as possible
to that of the invalid, illegal or unenforceable provisions.
Section 10.13. SURVIVAL. All rights and obligations arising hereunder
(including without limitation the representations and covenants set forth in
Article 4) shall survive until they are fully effectuated or performed.
Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, this Agreement shall
remain in effect and its provisions shall survive for the full period of all
applicable statutes of limitation (giving effect to any extension or waiver
thereof).
Section 10.14. CAPTIONS. The captions herein are included for convenience
of reference only and shall be ignored in the construction or interpretation
hereof.
Section 10.15. SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE. Each party to this Agreement
acknowledges and agrees that damages for a breach or threatened breach of any of
the provisions of this Agreement would be inadequate and irreparable harm would
occur. In recognition of this fact, each party agrees that, if there is a breach
or threatened breach, in addition to any damages, any of the nonbreaching
parties to this Agreement, without posting any bond, shall be entitled to seek
and obtain equitable relief in the form of specific performance, temporary
restraining order, temporary or permanent injunction, attachment, or any other
equitable remedy which may then be available to obligate the breaching party (i)
to perform its obligations under this Agreement, or (ii) if the breaching party
is unable, for whatever reason, to perform its obligations, to take any other
actions as are necessary, advisable or appropriate to give the other parties to
this Agreement the economic effect which comes as close as possible to the
performance of such obligations.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this Tax Sharing
Agreement to be duly executed by their respective authorized officers as of the
date first above written.
AETNA INC.
By: /s/ Xxxxxx X. Xxxxx, Xx.
--------------------------------
Name: Xxxxxx X. Xxxxx, Xx.
Title: Vice President, Finance & Treasurer
AETNA U.S. HEALTHCARE INC.
By: /s/ Xxxxxx X. Xxxxx, Xx.
--------------------------------
Name: Xxxxxx X. Xxxxx, Xx.
Title: Vice President, Finance & Treasurer
ING AMERICA INSURANCE HOLDINGS, INC.
By: /s/ B. Xxxxx Xxxxxx
--------------------------------
Name: B. Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Title: Assistant Secretary
