1
EXHIBIT 10.2
TAX SHARING AGREEMENT
AMONG
ALLEGHANY CORPORATION
AND
CHICAGO TITLE CORPORATION
2
TAX SHARING AGREEMENT
This Tax Sharing Agreement ("Agreement") is entered into as of June
17th, 1998, by and among Alleghany Corporation, a Delaware corporation
("Alleghany"), and Chicago Title Corporation, a Delaware corporation ("Chicago
Title").
RECITALS
WHEREAS, Alleghany is the common parent of an affiliated group of
corporations filing a consolidated Federal income tax return, which affiliated
group includes Chicago Title and Trust Company ("CT&T"); and
WHEREAS, The Chicago Trust Company ("TCTC") organized a new
corporation ("Newco"), and TCTC transferred all of the assets used in the
conduct of its land trust and land release business (the "Land Trust Business")
to Newco and Newco assumed all of the liabilities of, or relating to, the Land
Trust Business (the "Land Trust Contribution"); and
WHEREAS, TCTC distributed all of the shares of Newco to Alleghany
Asset Management, Inc. ("AAM"), and AAM distributed all of the Newco shares to
CT&T (together, the "Newco Distributions"); and
WHEREAS, CT&T has distributed all of the outstanding shares of
AAM to Alleghany (the "AAM Distribution"); and
WHEREAS, Alleghany will contribute all of the outstanding shares of
CT&T to Chicago Title, a newly-formed subsidiary of Alleghany (the date of such
contribution being the "CT&T Contribution Date"), and thereafter Alleghany will
distribute all of the outstanding shares of Chicago Title to Alleghany's
shareholders (the "Chicago Title Distribution"); and
3
WHEREAS, the Newco Distributions, the AAM Distribution and the
Chicago Title Distribution are all intended to qualify as tax-free distributions
under Section 355 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended ("Code"); and
WHEREAS, the parties desire to provide for, and agree upon, the
allocation between them of liabilities for all Taxes (as hereinafter defined)
arising prior to, as a result of, and subsequent to the transactions
contemplated by the Newco Distributions, the AAM Distribution and the Chicago
Title Distribution, and to provide for and agree upon other matters relating to
Taxes.
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual agreements contained
herein, the parties hereby agree as follows:
SECTION 1. Definition of Terms.
(a) Defined Terms. In addition to the capitalized terms otherwise
defined herein, the following terms shall have the following meaning:
"AAM Group" means AAM and each corporation which on the date of the
AAM Distribution was a member of the "affiliated group" of which AAM would be
the "common parent" (as such terms are defined or used in Section 1504(a) of the
Code), determined as if AAM were owned by individuals.
"Alleghany Consolidated Return" means any consolidated Federal
income tax return for the Alleghany Group.
"Alleghany Group" means Alleghany and all corporations which at the
time of reference would be members of the "affiliated group" of which Alleghany
is the "common parent" (as such terms are defined or used in Section 1504(a) of
the Code), so that on the day
2
4
after the Chicago Title Distribution Date, the term "Alleghany Group" excludes
any entity that is then a member of the Chicago Title Group.
"Business Day" shall mean any day other than a Saturday, a Sunday or
a day on which banks in New York, New York are authorized or obligated by law or
executive order to be closed for the transaction of business.
"Chicago Title Consolidated Tax Liability" means the hypothetical
liability for the Taxes imposed by Subtitle A or F of the Code which the Chicago
Title Group would have for the Tax Period of reference if the Chicago Title
Group had always filed its own consolidated Federal income tax return, computed
by assuming that (i) the Chicago Title Group was subject to Tax on all of its
taxable income at the applicable maximum federal income tax rates specified in
the Code, (ii) intercompany transactions between members of the Chicago Title
Group and the Alleghany Group that would be deferred under Treasury Regulation
Section 1.1502-13 are deferred and will be taken into account at the earlier of
the time provided under Treasury Regulation Section 1.1502-13 or on the Chicago
Title Distribution Date, (iii) any excess loss accounts (pursuant to Treasury
Regulation Section 1.1502-19) with respect to any stock of a member of the
Chicago Title Group shall be taken into account on the Chicago Title
Distribution Date, and (iv) with respect to any Pre-Distribution Period, in the
case of any item of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit that is computed or
subject to a limitation only on a consolidated basis, including but not limited
to, charitable contributions, capital losses, foreign tax credit, research and
experimentation credit and Section 1231 gains and losses, such items shall be
taken into account by Chicago Title only if, and to the extent (determined by
Alleghany on any
3
5
reasonable basis) that, such items are taken into account, and actually effects,
the amount of the liability for Tax of the Alleghany Group for the Tax Period of
reference.
"Chicago Title Distribution Date" means the date as of which
Alleghany exchanges with, or distributes to, its shareholders sufficient common
stock of Chicago Title as a result of which Chicago Title ceases to be a member
of the Alleghany Group as of the end of such day pursuant to Treasury Regulation
Section 1.1502-76(b)(1)(ii).
"Chicago Title Group" means, as the case may be, (i) Chicago Title
and those corporations which on the day after the Chicago Title Distribution
Date would be members of the "affiliated group" of which Chicago Title would be
the "common parent" (as such terms are defined or used in Section 1504(a) of the
Code), determined as if Chicago Title were owned by individuals, and (ii) with
respect to any Tax Period which includes or ends prior to the CT&T Contribution
Date, CT&T and those corporations which at and for the time of reference would
be members of the "affiliated group" of which CT&T would be the "common parent"
(as such terms are defined or used in Section 1504(a) of the Code), determined
as if CT&T were owned by individuals. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no member
of the AAM Group shall be treated as having ever been a member of the Chicago
Title Group, and Newco shall be treated as having always been a member of the
Chicago Title Group (but the foregoing shall not be construed as conferring any
liability upon the Chicago Title Group for any Tax imposed by Subtitle A or
Subtitle F of the Code with respect to the Land Trust Business prior to the date
of the Land Trust Contribution).
"Consolidated or Combined State Tax" means any Tax imposed by any
State or any political subdivision thereof which is (i) imposed on, or measured
by, gross or net receipts,
4
6
income, capital or net worth, including State and local franchise or similar
Taxes measured by net income, and (ii) computed on a consolidated, unitary or
combined basis by reference to the assets and/or activities of members of both
the Alleghany Group and the Chicago Title Group. Liability for
telecommunications, gross receipts (other than taxes on gross receipts that are
imposed in lieu of a tax on net receipts), transactional taxes, and sales and
use taxes, or other similar types of transactional taxes shall not be considered
a Consolidated or Combined State Tax for purposes of this Agreement.
"Payment Date" means the due date for any required installment of
estimated Taxes determined under Section 6655 of the Code, the due date
(determined without regard to extensions) for filing the Alleghany Consolidated
Return determined under Section 6072 of the Code, and the date the Alleghany
Consolidated Return is filed.
"Post-Distribution Period" means any Tax Period beginning on the day
after the Chicago Title Distribution Date, and, in the case of any Straddle
Period, the portion of such Straddle Period beginning on the day after the
Chicago Title Distribution Date.
"Pre-Distribution Period" means any Tax Period ending on or before
the Chicago Title Distribution Date, and, in the case of any Straddle Period,
the portion of such Straddle Period ending on the Chicago Title Distribution
Date.
"Ruling Request" means the letter, dated November 12, 1997,
submitted on behalf of Alleghany to the Internal Revenue Service requesting a
letter ruling regarding certain income tax consequences of the AAM Distribution
and the Chicago Title Distribution (including all attachments, exhibits, and
other materials submitted with such ruling request letter), and all amendments
or supplements to such ruling request letter.
5
7
"Straddle Period" means any Tax Period that begins on or before and
ends after the Chicago Title Distribution Date.
"Tax" or "Taxes" means any income, gross income, gross receipts,
profits, capital stock, franchise, withholding, payroll, social security,
workers compensation, unemployment, disability, property, ad valorem, stamp,
excise, severance, occupation, service, sales, use, license, lease, transfer,
import, export, value added, alternative minimum, estimated or other similar tax
(including any fee, assessment, or other charge in the nature of or in lieu of
any tax) imposed by any governmental entity or political subdivision thereof,
and any interest, penalties, additions to tax, or additional amounts in respect
of the foregoing.
"Tax Law" means any law (other than the Code) of any governmental
entity or political subdivision thereof relating to any Tax.
"Tax Period" means, with respect to any Tax, the period for which
the Tax is reported as provided under the Code or other applicable Tax Law.
"Treasury Regulations" means the regulations promulgated from time
to time under the Code as in effect for the relevant Tax Period.
(b) Interpretation of Terms. Unless otherwise indicated, the words
and concepts used in this Agreement shall be given the same definitions and
meanings ascribed to them by the Code, the Treasury Regulations or other Tax
Law. Any alteration, modification, addition, deletion, or other change in the
applicable provisions of the Code, the Treasury Regulations or other Tax Law
shall automatically be applicable to this Agreement mutatis mutandis. Unless
otherwise indicated, all references herein to a particular section of the Code,
6
8
the Treasury Regulations or other Tax Law shall include any successor provision
designated by a different or additional section reference.
SECTION 2. Allocation of Tax Liabilities.
2.01 Chicago Title Liability. For each Tax Period for which any
member of the Chicago Title Group was also a member of the Alleghany Group,
Chicago Title shall be liable for, and shall indemnify and hold harmless
Alleghany and each member of the Alleghany Group (excluding any member of the
Chicago Title Group) from and against, the amount of (a) the Chicago Title
Consolidated Tax Liability for the Tax Period of reference over (b) the net
amount theretofore paid by the Chicago Title Group to Alleghany on account of
the Chicago Title Consolidated Tax Liability for the Tax Period of reference.
2.02 Alleghany Liability. Provided that Chicago Title and the
members of the Chicago Title Group have performed all of their obligations under
this Agreement, Alleghany shall be liable for, and shall indemnify and hold
harmless Chicago Title and each member of the Chicago Title Group from and
against any liability for Taxes of the Alleghany Group imposed by Subtitle A or
F of the Code or Chapter 43 of Subtitle D of the Code.
2.03 AAM Liability. Except as otherwise provided herein with respect
to Consolidated or Combined State Income Taxes and as may be required to allow
CT&T to exclude from its income pursuant to Treasury Regulation
1.1502-13(f)(2)(ii) any dividend from AAM, AAM shall be treated as having never
been a member of the Chicago Title Group, and, except as specifically provided
herein, Chicago Title shall have no liability for, and shall be indemnified and
be held harmless from, the liability for Taxes of AAM or any member of the AAM
Group imposed by Subtitle A or F of the Code.
7
9
2.04 Allocation of All Other Taxes. Except as provided in Section
2.05, all Taxes other than those specifically allocated pursuant to Sections
2.01 through 2.03 shall be allocated based on the legal entity on which the
legal incidence of the Tax is imposed, determined without regard to any joint
and several liability any other legal entity would have as a result of
membership in any controlled group.
2.05 Chicago Title Liability for Transaction and Certain Other
Taxes.
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, Chicago
Title shall be liable for, and shall indemnify and hold harmless Alleghany from
and against any liability for, Taxes arising from the Land Trust Contribution,
the Newco Distributions, the AAM Distribution or the Chicago Title Distribution
as follows:
(a) any sales, use, stock, real property or other transfer Taxes
imposed on the transfers occurring in connection with, or pursuant to, the Land
Trust Contribution, the Newco Distributions and the Chicago Title Distribution;
(b) any Tax resulting from any income or gain recognized by the
Chicago Title Group under Treasury Regulation Sections 1.1502-13 or 1.1502-19
(or any corresponding provisions of other applicable Tax Laws) as a result of
the Chicago Title Distribution; and
(c) any Tax resulting for any reason whatsoever from any income or
gain recognized by Alleghany as a result of either the contribution of CT&T to
Chicago Title or the Chicago Title Distribution failing to qualify for tax-free
treatment under Sections 351, 355, 361, 368 or other provisions of the Code (as
contemplated in the Ruling Request) or other applicable Tax Laws;
8
10
(d) any Tax resulting from any income or gain recognized by
Alleghany (including any member of the AAM Group) as a result of the AAM
Distribution failing to qualify for tax-free treatment under Sections 351, 355,
361, 368 or other provisions of the Code (as contemplated in the Ruling Request)
or other applicable Tax Laws by reason of the inaccuracy of any factual
statements or representations relating to Chicago Title or any member of the
Chicago Title Group in connection with the Ruling Request, or from any breach of
Chicago Title's representations or covenants under Section 9 or any Chicago
Title Tainting Act (as defined in Section 9) by Chicago Title or any member of
the Chicago Title Group; and
(e) any Tax resulting for any reason whatsoever from any income or
gain recognized by Alleghany (including any member of the AAM Group) as a result
of either the Land Trust Contribution or the Newco Distributions failing to
qualify for tax-free treatment under Sections 351, 355, 361, 368 or other
provisions of the Code or other applicable Tax laws.
2.06 General Method of Proration. In determining the Tax for the
Pre-Distribution Period and the Post-Distribution Period, items of income, gain,
loss, deduction, and credit shall be apportioned between such periods based upon
a closing of the books for Tax purposes and in accordance with the principles of
Treasury Regulation Section 1.1502-76(b), as reasonably interpreted and applied
by Alleghany and Chicago Title. For this purpose, Chicago Title's books for
accounting and Tax purposes shall close at the close of business on the Chicago
Title Distribution Date. No election shall be made under Treasury Regulation
Section 1.1502-76(b)(2)(ii) (relating to ratable allocation of a year's items),
and Treasury Regulation Section 1.1502-76(b)(2)(iii) will be applied to ratably
allocate the items (other than extraordinary items, including, without limiting
the generality of the foregoing, compensation items) for the
9
11
month which includes the Chicago Title Distribution Date. Any items of income,
gain, loss, deduction and credit relating to the Chicago Title Distribution
shall be treated as an extraordinary item described in Treasury Regulation
Section 1.1502-76(b)(2)(ii)(C) and shall be allocated to the Pre-Distribution
Period, and any Taxes related to such items shall be treated under Treasury
Regulation Section 1.1502-76(b)(2)(iv) as relating to such extraordinary item
and shall be allocated to the Pre-Distribution Period.
2.07 Consolidated or Combined State Taxes for Straddle Periods. Any
Consolidated or Combined State Taxes for a Straddle Period shall be allocated
between the members of the Alleghany Group and the Chicago Title Group first on
the basis of, and to the extent, that the receipts, income, capital or net worth
of a member resulted in, or increased, any Consolidated or Combined State Taxes.
Any remaining Consolidated or Combined State Taxes for a Straddle Period shall
be allocated among the members on the basis on which each member's relative
attribute (whether positive or negative) was taken into account in determining
the amount of any Consolidated or Combined State Tax contributed to the
remainder of the Consolidated or Combined State Taxes for the Straddle Period.
2.08 Adjustment of Tax Liability. If any item of income, gain, loss,
expense, deduction or credit that enters into the computation of the Chicago
Title Consolidated Tax Liability or the Consolidated or Combined State Taxes for
the Straddle Period is changed or adjusted by the Internal Revenue Service or by
a State or local tax authority and such change or adjustment is part of a final
settlement with the Internal Revenue Service or a State or local tax authority
that is binding on all parties or, if applicable, a final judicial decision upon
the expiration of the time for the decision to be appealed (a "final
determination"), Alleghany shall
10
12
make such payments to Chicago Title or Chicago Title shall make such payments to
Alleghany (including interest, penalties and additions to Tax imposed on the
Alleghany Group or any member of the Alleghany Group) in connection with the
adjustment or change as may be necessary to adjust the payments between Chicago
Title and Alleghany to reflect payments that would have been made under Sections
2.01 through 2.07 of this Agreement had the adjustments as finally determined
been taken into account in determining the amount of the payments under Sections
2.01 through 2.07. A payment required under this Section 2.08 shall be due and
payable ten (10) Business Days following the date that one party gives notice to
the other party that a payment is due. Notice under this Section 2.08 shall
include a copy of the notice of deficiency or other written communication from a
Tax authority describing the final determination and, if appropriate or
necessary, detailed calculations supporting the amount due.
SECTION 3. Preparation and Filing of Tax Returns.
3.01 Alleghany Consolidated Returns. The Alleghany Consolidated
Return required to be filed for any Tax Period shall be prepared by Alleghany.
For any prior Tax Period for which the Alleghany Consolidated Return has not
been filed by the Chicago Title Distribution Date and for the Tax Period which
includes the Chicago Title Distribution Date, Chicago Title shall provide
Alleghany with (i) a true and correct tax return for the Chicago Title Group,
together with an accompanying computation of Tax liability of the Chicago Title
Group, (ii) separate tax returns for each member of the Chicago Title Group
together with accompanying computations of the separate return Tax liabilities
of each member of the Chicago Title Group, and (iii) a reconciliation of book
income to Federal taxable income for each member of the Chicago Title Group.
Chicago Title agrees to use reasonable efforts in good faith to provide
11
13
Alleghany with such returns and computations no later than the first day of the
sixth month following the end of the Tax Period to which such returns and
computations relate, but in any event shall provide such returns and
computations to Alleghany no later than the fifteenth day of the seventh month
following the end of the Tax Period to which such returns and computations
relate.
3.02 Consolidated or Combined State Tax Returns. Any returns
reporting Consolidated or Combined State Tax for any Pre-Distribution Period and
any Straddle Period shall be prepared and filed when due (including extensions)
by the person obligated to file such return of Consolidated or Combined State
Tax under the applicable Tax Law. Alleghany and Chicago Title shall provide, and
shall cause the members of their respective affiliated groups to provide,
assistance and shall cooperate with one another in accordance with Section 5
with respect to the preparation and filing of any return reporting Consolidated
or Combined State Tax, including providing information required to be provided
in Section 5, for Pre-Distribution Periods or Straddle Periods not filed by the
Chicago Title Distribution Date.
3.03 Manner of Filing. All returns of Tax filed, or caused to be
filed, by Alleghany or Chicago Title after the Chicago Title Distribution Date
shall be (in the absence of a controlling change in law, facts or
circumstances), (a) prepared on a basis that is consistent with the Ruling
Request and any letter ruling of the Internal Revenue Service obtained by
Alleghany in connection with the AAM Distribution and the Chicago Title
Distribution, (b) with respect to any Tax Period that includes the Chicago Title
Distribution Date, filed on a timely basis (including permitted extensions of
time for filing) by the party responsible for such filing under this Agreement
and (c) with respect to any Tax Period that includes the Chicago Title
12
14
Distribution Date, prepared consistent with past practices, elections,
accounting methods, conventions, and principles of taxation used for the most
recent taxable periods for which the Tax returns involving similar items have
been filed prior to the Chicago Title Distribution Date. With respect to all
Pre-Distribution Tax Periods and the Tax Period which includes the Chicago Title
Distribution Date, all elections that are available to the Alleghany Group under
the Treasury Regulations relating to the filing of consolidated Federal income
tax returns and all Tax return filing positions for all Tax Periods shall be
made by Alleghany in its sole discretion.
SECTION 4. Tax Payments.
4.01 Payment of Taxes with Respect to Alleghany Consolidated Returns
Filed After the Chicago Title Distribution Date. In the case of any Alleghany
Consolidated Return the due date for which (including extensions) is after the
Chicago Title Distribution Date, at least ten (10) Business Days prior to any
Payment Date, Chicago Title shall compute and submit to Alleghany its estimate
of the amount of the Chicago Title Consolidated Tax Liability for the Tax Period
which would be required to be paid by Chicago Title on such Payment Date if the
Chicago Title Group were a separate affiliated group, assuming that the required
payment was sufficient to avoid incurring any addition to tax under Section 6655
of the Code by reason of an underpayment by a "large corporation" within the
meaning of Section 6655(g)(2) of the Code. The amount so estimated shall be
consistent with the elections under Section 6655(d) and (e) of the Code made or
to be made by Alleghany, in its sole discretion, for such taxable year.
Alleghany shall review the estimated amount as calculated by Chicago
Title, and Alleghany shall conclusively determine in good faith the amount of
Tax required to be paid by Chicago Title on that Payment Date. Alleghany shall
notify Chicago Title in writing at least
13
15
three (3) Business Days prior to any Payment Date of the amount of Tax required
to be paid by Chicago Title to Alleghany prior to such Payment Date. Within one
(1) business day preceding any Payment Date, Chicago Title will pay to Alleghany
the excess (if any) of:
(i) the Chicago Title Consolidated Tax Liability determined as of
such Payment Date with respect to the applicable Tax Period, over
(ii) the cumulative payments with respect to such Tax Period prior
to such Payment Date made by Chicago Title or by CT&T.
4.02 Agreement Regarding Cumulative 1997 and 1998 Federal Income Tax
Payments. Alleghany and Chicago Title agree that, as of the date hereof, the
cumulative payments made, or deemed made for purposes of this Agreement by
Chicago Title with respect to the year 1997 is $37,765,466, and with respect to
the year 1998 is $29,356,050.
4.03 Payment of Consolidated or Combined State Tax Relating to
Returns Filed After the Chicago Title Distribution Date. The provisions of
Section 4.01 shall be equally applicable with respect to any Consolidated or
Combined State Tax relating to any Pre-Distribution Period or Straddle Period.
4.04 Method of Payment. All payments required by this Agreement
shall be made by (i) wire transfer (by no later than 1:00 p.m. Eastern time on
the required date of payment) to the appropriate bank account as may from time
to time be designated by the parties for such purpose, provided that on the date
of such wire transfer notice of the transfer is given to the recipient thereof
in accordance with Section 17.01 of this Agreement or (ii) any other method
agreed to by the parties. All payments due under this Agreement shall be deemed
to be paid when available funds are actually received by the payee.
14
16
SECTION 5. Assistance and Cooperation. After the Chicago Title
Distribution Date, each of Alleghany and Chicago Title shall cooperate in good
faith (and cause the respective members of their affiliated groups to cooperate)
with each other and with each other's agents, including accounting firms and
legal counsel, in connection with Tax matters relating to the Alleghany Group
and the Chicago Title Group, including (i) preparation and filing of Tax
returns, (ii) determining the liability for, and amount of, any Taxes due
(including estimated Taxes) or the right to and amount of any refund of Taxes,
(iii) examinations of Tax returns, (iv) the determination of the basis of the
stock of any corporation, and (v) any administrative or judicial proceeding in
respect of Taxes assessed or proposed to be assessed. Each of Alleghany and
Chicago Title shall also make available to each other, as reasonably requested
and available, personnel (including officers, directors, employees and agents of
Alleghany and Chicago Title or members of their respective affiliated group)
responsible for preparing, maintaining, and interpreting information and
documents relevant to Taxes, and personnel reasonably required as witnesses or
for purposes of providing information or documents in connection with any
administrative or judicial proceeding relating to Taxes. Any information or
documents provided under this Section 5 shall be kept confidential by the person
receiving the information or documents, except as may otherwise be necessary in
connection with the filing of Tax returns or in connection with any
administrative or judicial proceeding relating to Taxes.
SECTION 6. Tax Records.
6.01 Retention of Tax Records. Each of Alleghany and Chicago Title
shall, and shall cause the members of their respective affiliated groups, to
preserve and keep all reports of Taxes due, any claims for refund of Taxes paid,
any information return with respect to Taxes,
15
17
or any other similar report, statement, declaration, or document required to be
filed under the Code or other Tax Law, including any attachments, exhibits, or
other materials submitted with any of the foregoing, and including any
amendments or supplements to any of the foregoing ("Tax Returns"), Tax Return
work papers, documentation relating to any audit, review, examination, or any
other administrative or judicial proceeding with the purpose or effect of
redetermining Taxes, and any other books of account or records required to be
maintained under the Code or other applicable Tax Laws or under any record
retention agreement with any Tax authority ("Tax Records") exclusively relating
to the assets and activities of their respective affiliated groups for
Pre-Distribution Tax Periods and any Straddle Periods for so long as the
contents thereof may become material in the administration of any matter under
the Code or other applicable Tax Law, but in any event until the later of (i)
the expiration of any applicable statutes of limitation, and (ii) seven years
after the Chicago Title Distribution Date. If, prior to the expiration of the
applicable statute of limitation and such seven-year period, Alleghany or
Chicago Title reasonably determines that any Tax Records which it is required to
preserve and keep under this Section 6 are no longer material in the
administration of any matter under the Code or other applicable Tax Law,
Alleghany or Chicago Title, as the case may be, may dispose, or may permit the
members of their respective affiliated groups to dispose, of such records upon
90 days' prior notice to the other party. Such notice shall include a list of
the records to be disposed of describing in reasonable detail each file, book,
or other record accumulation being disposed. The notified person shall have the
opportunity, at its cost and expense, to copy or remove, within such 90-day
period, all or any part of such Tax Records.
16
18
6.02 Access to Tax Records. Alleghany and Chicago Title shall make,
and shall cause the members of their respective affiliated groups to make,
available to each other for inspection and copying during normal business hours
upon reasonable notice all Tax Records in their possession to the extent
reasonably required by the other party in connection with the preparation of Tax
Returns, audits, litigation, the determination of basis, or the resolution of
items under this Agreement.
SECTION 7. Tax Contests.
7.01 Notice. Each of Alleghany or Chicago Title, as the case may be,
shall provide prompt notice to the other of any pending or threatened Tax audit,
assessment or proceeding or other Tax contest of which it or any member of their
respective affiliated groups receives any written communication related to Taxes
for Tax Periods for which Alleghany or Chicago Title is, or may be, indemnified
by the other party hereunder. Such notice shall contain factual information (to
the extent known) describing any asserted Tax liability in reasonable detail and
shall be accompanied by copies of any notice and other documents received from
any Tax authority in respect of any such matters. If an indemnified party
receives any written communication of an asserted Tax liability with respect to
a matter for which it is to be indemnified hereunder and such party fails to
give the indemnifying party prompt notice of such asserted Tax liability, then
(i) if the indemnifying party is precluded from contesting the asserted Tax
liability in any forum as a result of the failure to give prompt notice, the
indemnifying party shall have no obligation to indemnify the indemnified party
for any Taxes arising out of such asserted Tax liability, and (ii) if the
indemnifying party is not precluded from contesting the asserted Tax liability
in any forum, but such failure to give prompt notice results in a monetary
17
19
detriment to the indemnifying party, then any amount which the indemnifying
party is otherwise required to pay the indemnified party pursuant to this
Agreement shall be reduced by the amount of such detriment.
7.02 Control of Tax Contests. Alleghany shall have full
responsibility and discretion in handling, settling or contesting any Tax audit
or contest involving a Tax reported on the Alleghany Consolidated Return;
provided, however, that with respect to any Tax for which Chicago Title has
liability under this Agreement, Alleghany shall consult with, and consider in
good faith any suggestions of, Chicago Title, shall keep Chicago Title informed
as to the progress of any Tax audit or contest and, if requested by Chicago
Title, shall consult with, and consider in good faith any recommendation by,
Chicago Title (or its counsel) concerning the conduct of such Tax audit or
contest.
In the case of any return involving any Combined or Consolidated
State Tax, the person responsible under the Tax Law for the preparation and
filing of such return shall have full responsibility and discretion in handling,
settling or contesting any Tax audit or contest involving any Combined or
Consolidated State Tax; provided, however, that the person with such
responsibility shall consult with, and consider in good faith any suggestions
of, the other with respect to any Tax for which such other person has liability
under this Agreement.
SECTION 8. Effective Date; Termination of Prior Tax Sharing
Agreements. This Agreement shall be effective on the Chicago Title Distribution
Date. Immediately prior to the Chicago Title Distribution Date, any written or
oral agreement or any other arrangements relating to the allocation of Taxes
existing between Alleghany and any member of the Alleghany Group and any member
of the Chicago Title Group (other than this Agreement) shall be
18
20
terminated, and neither party shall thereafter have any liability or obligation
(whether in respect of past or future Taxes) to the other under any prior tax
allocation agreement.
SECTION 9. No Inconsistent Actions.
9.01 Chicago Title Agreements. Chicago Title covenants and agrees
that it will not take any action, and it will cause each member of the Chicago
Title Group to refrain from taking any action, which may be inconsistent with
the Tax treatment of the AAM Distribution or the Chicago Title Distribution as
contemplated in the Ruling Request (any such action is referred to in this
Section 9 as a "Chicago Title Tainting Act"), unless (i) Chicago Title either
(A) obtains a ruling with respect to the Tainting Act from the Internal Revenue
Service or other applicable Tax Authority that is reasonably satisfactory to
Alleghany (except that neither Chicago Title nor any member of the Chicago Title
Group shall submit any such ruling request if Alleghany determines in good faith
that filing such request might have a materially adverse effect upon Alleghany),
or (B) obtains an unqualified opinion of independent nationally recognized tax
counsel acceptable to Alleghany, on a basis of assumed facts and representations
consistent with the facts at the time of such action, that such Tainting Act
will not adversely affect the Tax treatment of the AAM Distribution or the
Chicago Title Distribution as contemplated in the Ruling Request, or (ii)
Alleghany consents in writing to such Tainting Act, which consent shall be
granted or withheld in the sole and absolute discretion of Alleghany.
Without limiting the foregoing, during the two-year period following
the Chicago Title Distribution Date, unless clause (i) or (ii) of the preceding
paragraph is satisfied with respect to the applicable action, neither Chicago
Title nor CT&T will (a) liquidate or merge with or into any other corporation;
(b) issue more than 20 percent, by vote or value, of its capital stock
19
21
in one or more transactions; (c) redeem, purchase or otherwise reacquire more
than five (5) percent, by vote or value, of its capital stock in one or more
transactions (other than in connection with future employee benefit plans or
pursuant to a future market purchase program involving five (5) percent or less
of its publicly traded stock); (d) sell, exchange, distribute or otherwise
dispose of, other than in the ordinary course of business, more than 25 percent
of the assets constituting the trades or businesses relied upon in the Ruling
Request to satisfy Section 355(b) of the Code; or (e) discontinue or cause to be
discontinued the active conduct of the trades or businesses relied upon in the
Ruling Request to satisfy Section 355(b) of the Code.
9.02 No Inconsistent Plan or Intent. Chicago Title represents and
warrants that neither Chicago Title nor any of the members of the Chicago Title
Group has any plan or intent to take any action which is inconsistent with any
factual statements or representations in the Ruling Request. Regardless of any
change in circumstances, Chicago Title covenants and agrees that Chicago Title
will not take, and it will cause the members of the Chicago Title Group to
refrain from taking, any such inconsistent action on or before the second
anniversary of the Chicago Title Distribution Date, other than as permitted in
this Section 9.
9.03 Chicago Title Indemnity. Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary in this Agreement, Chicago Title shall be solely liable for, and shall
indemnify and hold harmless Alleghany and members of the Alleghany Group
(including members of the AAM Group) from any Tax (a) resulting from a Chicago
Title Tainting Act by Chicago Title or the members of the Chicago Title Group,
regardless of whether clause (i) or (ii) of Section 9.01 was satisfied with
respect to such Tainting Act and (b) on, based upon, or resulting from, the Land
Trust Contribution and the Newco Distributions.
20
22
9.04 Exclusion From Indemnity. Notwithstanding the provisions of
Section 2.05 and this Section 9, Chicago Title shall have no liability for, and
shall not be obligated to indemnify and hold harmless Alleghany and members of
the Alleghany Group (including members of the AAM Group) from any Tax which
results solely and directly from, and then only to the extent attributable to,
(a) any errors or omissions in the factual statements or representations made in
the Ruling Request relating to Alleghany or members of the Alleghany Group,
excluding the Chicago Title Group, or (b) the taking, or the failure to take, by
Alleghany or, after the date of the AAM Distribution, any member of the AAM
Group of any action which is inconsistent with any factual statements or
representations relating to Alleghany or, as to actions or inactions after the
date of the AAM Distribution, by any members of the AAM Group, in the Ruling
Request (any error or omission in clause (a) or the taking or failure to take in
clause (b) being referred to herein as an "Alleghany Tainting Act."). Chicago
Title shall be relieved of its liability for, or its obligation to indemnify
hereunder only if, or to the extent that, Chicago Title would have had no
liability, or its liability would have been reduced, had no Alleghany Tainting
Act occurred. For this purpose, no account shall be taken of the increased
possibility of discovery caused by reason of any Alleghany Tainting Act nor the
effect of any other act (including by way of illustration and not by way of
limitation, any extension by Alleghany of any statute of limitations).
SECTION 10. Carrybacks.
10.01 Waiver of Carrybacks. Chicago Title agrees that Chicago Title
shall make all available elections to waive or relinquish the right to claim in,
or carryback to, any Tax Period for which any member of the Chicago Title Group
was also a member of the Alleghany Group
21
23
arising in a Post-Distribution Period, and Chicago Title shall make no
affirmative election to claim any such carryback of any net operating loss, net
capital loss, unused or excess tax credit, or other similar deductible or
creditable Tax items which may or must be carried from any Post-Distribution
Period back to a Pre-Distribution Period under the Code.
10.02 Permitted Carrybacks. If notwithstanding the making of all
available elections, Chicago Title is required to claim in, or carryback to, any
Tax Period for which any member of the Chicago Title Group was also a member of
the Alleghany Group any deductible or creditable Tax items from any
Post-Distribution Period (a "carryback item"), then Alleghany shall pay to
Chicago Title promptly after the same is received (or credited against any other
Tax obligation of Alleghany) the amount of any refund of Tax in a
Pre-Distribution Period received (or credited against another Tax) attributable
to a carryback item; provided, however, that the amount of such refund payable
to Chicago Title shall not exceed the reduction in the Chicago Title
Consolidated Tax Liability for the Pre-Distribution Period attributable to the
carryback item.
SECTION 11. Survival of Obligations. The representations,
warranties, covenants and agreements set forth in this Agreement shall be
unconditional and absolute and shall remain in effect without limitation as to
time.
SECTION 12. Treatment of Payments; Tax Gross Up.
12.01 Treatment of Tax Indemnity Payments. In the absence of any
change in tax treatment under the Code or other applicable Tax Law, any Tax
indemnity payments made by Alleghany or Chicago Title under Sections 2 or 9,
shall be reported for Tax purposes by the payor and the recipient as
distributions or capital contributions, as appropriate, occurring
22
24
immediately before the Chicago Title Distribution Date, but only to the extent
the payment does not relate to a Tax allocated to the payor in accordance with
Treasury Regulation Section 1.1502-33(d) (or under corresponding principles of
other applicable Tax Laws).
12.02 Tax Gross-Up. If notwithstanding the manner in which Tax
indemnity payments were reported, there is an adjustment to the Tax liability of
Alleghany or Chicago Title as a result of its receipt or accrual of a payment
pursuant to this Agreement, such payment shall be appropriately adjusted so that
the amount of such payment, reduced by the amount of all Taxes payable with
respect to the receipt or accrual thereof (but taking into account all
correlative Tax savings resulting from the payment of such Taxes), shall equal
the amount of the payment which the company receiving such payment would
otherwise be entitled to receive pursuant to this Agreement.
SECTION 13. Disagreements and Disputes.
13.01 Disagreements as to Calculations, Returns, etc. If after good
faith negotiations Alleghany and Chicago Title cannot agree on the application
of this Agreement to the matters referred to in Sections 2.06, 2.08, 3.03,
10.01, 10.02 and 12.02, then such matter (and only such matters) will be
referred to a nationally recognized accounting firm acceptable to both Alleghany
and Chicago Title (the "Accounting Firm"). The Accounting Firm shall furnish
written notice to Alleghany and Chicago Title of its resolution of any such
disagreement as soon as practical, but in any event no later than 45 days after
its acceptance of the matter for resolution. Any such resolution by the
Accounting Firm will be conclusive and binding on Alleghany and Chicago Title.
In accordance with Section 16, each of Alleghany and Chicago Title shall pay its
own fees and expenses (including the fees and expenses of its representatives)
23
25
incurred in connection with the referral of the matter to the Accounting Firm.
All fees and expenses of the Accounting Firm in connection with such referral
shall be shared equally by Alleghany and Chicago Title.
SECTION 14. Late Payments. Any amount owed by one party to another
party under this Agreement which is not paid when due shall bear interest at the
base rate on corporate loans charged by Chase Manhattan Bank, N.A., New York,
New York from time to time, compounded daily on the basis of a year of 365 or
366 (as applicable) days and actual days elapsed, plus two (2) percentage
points, compounded semiannually, from the due date of the payment to the date
paid. To the extent interest required to be paid under this Section 14
duplicates interest required to be paid under any other provision of this
Agreement, interest shall be computed at the higher of the interest rate
provided under this Section 14 or the interest rate provided under such other
provision.
SECTION 15. Setoff. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this
Agreement, each of Alleghany and Chicago Title has the right to collect payments
under this Agreement that are more than sixty (60) calendar days past due by
setoff against payments due to the other party under this Agreement or any other
agreement between them. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, in the event and
to the extent that any payment to be made under this Agreement is in dispute
between the parties and the disputed matter is subject to the dispute resolution
procedure set forth in Section 13 of this Agreement, the setoff provision of
this Section 15 shall not apply to the extent of the disputed amount.
SECTION 16. Expenses. Except as provided in Section 13, each of
Alleghany and Chicago Title and members of their respective affiliated groups
shall bear their own
24
26
expenses incurred in connection with preparation of Tax returns, Tax contests,
and other matters related to Taxes under the provisions of this Agreement.
SECTION 17. General Provisions.
17.01 Addresses and Notices. Any notice, demand, request or report
required or permitted to be given or made to any party under this Agreement
shall be in writing and shall be deemed given or made when delivered to a party
or when sent by first class mail or by other commercially reasonable means of
written communication (including delivery by an internationally recognized
courier service or by facsimile transmission) to the party at the party's
address as follows:
If to Alleghany, at:
Alleghany Corporation
000 Xxxx Xxxxxx
Xxx Xxxx, Xxx Xxxx 00000
Attn: General Counsel
Telecopy number: (000) 000-0000
with a copy to:
Shereff, Friedman, Xxxxxxx & Xxxxxxx, LLP
000 Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxx Xxxx, Xxx Xxxx 00000-0000
Attn: Xxxxxxx X. Xxxxxxx, Esq.
Telecopy number: (000) 000-0000
If to Chicago Title, at:
Chicago Title Corp.
000 Xxxxx Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxx 00000
Attn: General Counsel
Telecopy number: (000) 000-0000
25
27
with a copy to:
Chicago Title Corp.
000 Xxxxx Xxxxx Xxxxxx
Xxxxxxx, Xxxxxxxx 00000
Attn: Chief Financial Officer
Telecopy number: (000) 000-0000
A party may change the address for receiving notices under this
Agreement by providing written notice of the change of address to the other
parties.
17.02 Binding Effect. This Agreement shall be binding upon and inure
to the benefit of the parties hereto and their successors and assigns.
17.03 Waiver. No failure by any party to insist upon the strict
performance of any obligation under this Agreement or to exercise any right or
remedy under this Agreement shall constitute waiver of any such obligation,
right, or remedy or any other obligation, rights, or remedies under this
Agreement.
17.04 Invalidity of Provisions. If any provision of this Agreement
is or becomes invalid, illegal or unenforceable in any respect, the validity,
legality, and enforceability of the remaining provisions contained herein shall
not be affected thereby.
17.05 Further Action. The parties shall execute and deliver all
documents, provide all information, and take or refrain from taking action as
may be necessary or appropriate to achieve the purposes of this Agreement,
including the execution and delivery to the other parties and their Affiliates
and representatives of such powers of attorney or other authorizing
documentation as is reasonably necessary or appropriate in connection with Tax
contests (or portions thereof) under the control of such other parties in
accordance with Section 7.
26
28
17.06 Integration. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement
among the parties pertaining to the subject matter of this Agreement and
supersedes all prior agreements and understanding pertaining thereto.
17.07 Construction. The language in all parts of this Agreement
shall in all cases be construed according to its fair meaning and shall not be
strictly construed for or against any party
17.08 No Double Recovery; Subrogation. No provision of this
Agreement shall be construed to provide an indemnity or other recovery for any
costs, damages, or other amounts for which the damaged party has been fully
compensated under any other provision of this Agreement or under any other
agreement or action at law or equity. Unless expressly required in this
Agreement, a party shall not be required to exhaust all remedies available under
other agreements or at law or equity before recovering under the remedies
provided in this Agreement. Subject to any limitations provided in this
Agreement, the indemnifying party shall be subrogated to all rights of the
indemnified party for recovery from any third party.
17.09 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in two or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, and all of which taken
together shall constitute one and the same instrument.
17.10 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and
construed in accordance with the laws of the State of New York applicable to
contracts executed in and to be performed in that State.
27
29
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have caused this Agreement to be
executed by the respective officers as of the date set forth above.
ALLEGHANY CORPORATION
By: /s/ Xxxxx X. Xxxxxxxx
----------------------------------
Title:
CHICAGO TITLE CORPORATION
By: /s/ Xxxx X. Xxxxx, Xx.
----------------------------------
Title: Executive Vice President
28
