EXHIBIT 10.33
REVISED OPERATING AGREEMENT
This Revised Operating Agreement (this "Agreement") is dated as of October
27, 2004 (the "Effective Date"), is made and entered into between DTE Energy
Trading, Inc., a Michigan corporation ("Supplier"), and Commonwealth Energy
Corporation, a California corporation ("Buyer") and supercedes the Revised
Operating Agreement between the Parties dated July 24, 2003. Buyer and Supplier
are each a "Party" and, collectively, are the "Parties."
RECITALS
WHEREAS, Supplier is a power marketer that makes wholesale electricity
sales to third parties. Buyer is in the business of providing electricity
services to retail customers in Michigan (collectively, the "Customers") under
the Detroit Edison Electric Choice Program (the "DECo Program"). Buyer agrees
that supply it purchases from Supplier will only be used to serve its Customers
within the DECo Program. Moreover, because of certain credit concessions that
Supplier is making. Buyer agrees that Supplier will be its primary Energy
supplier for its Customers in the DECo Program; however, Buyer has the right to
purchase Energy from an alternative supplier under the terms of Article 4
herein. Nonetheless, Supplier is not precluded from selling wholesale Energy
supply to other alternative electric suppliers ("AES") other than Buyer that are
participating in the DECo Program;
AND WHEREAS, Buyer agrees to purchase full or partial requirements Energy
supply products from Supplier pursuant to a series of supply Transaction
Confirmations) ("Confirmations") governed by the EEI Master Power Purchase and
Sale Agreement executed by the Parties dated July 1, 2003 (the EEI Master
Agreement"). The Parties will determine whether a particular Transaction or set
of Transactions will be for full or partial requirements Energy supply, and such
Transaction(s) will be memorialized in each relevant Confirmation. Nevertheless,
each Transaction will be for a fixed, maximum amount of supply at a fixed price,
and, depending on the product, there may also be a fixed, minimum amount of
supply at a fixed price ("Transaction Program(s)"). In the case of full
requirements Energy supply, Supplier will hold open each Transaction Program to
new Customers for the earlier of: six (6) months or until Buyer has allocated
the maximum amount of supply for its Customers; provided, however, that the
relevant Transaction Program will remain open to new Customers unless the
volumetric, weighted average of the Cinergy On-Peak forward market price for all
available July, August, January, and February months (within a window equal to
the number of months of the Customer term under the Delivery Period as set forth
in each relevant Transaction) beginning the third month after the month in which
each Transaction is executed changes by more than 10% when compared to the
volumetric, weighted average of the Cinergy On-Peak forward market price for all
available July, August, January, and February months (within the same window
specified above) beginning the third month after the current month for each day
of the six (6)-month window. If the above-referenced forward market price change
threshold is triggered, then Supplier will provide Buyer a seven (7)-Business
Day notice that Supplier is closing the Transaction Program to new Customers.
During the pendency of the 7-Business Day notice period, Buyer may finalize
contract negotiations with new Customers, as available, for up to ten percent
(10%) of the maximum amount of supply specified in the relevant Transaction,
provided however, that the maximum amount of supply to be provided under each
Transaction cannot exceed the maximum amount of supply specified in each
Transaction. After the notice period has expired, the Transaction Program may be
closed to new Customers. Upon acceptance by Supplier of each Customer under the
relevant Transaction Program, the Buyer's contract pricing associated with each
Customer remains in effect for up to two (2) years.
AND WHEREAS, under certain circumstances, Supplier agrees to supply
Buyer's Customers with full requirements Energy supply under Transactions where
Supplier, rather than Buyer, assumes substantial risk related to firm Energy
supply, aggregate Customer load
forecasting and transmission and ancillary services, including imbalance
charges;
AND WHEREAS, in other circumstances. Supplier agrees to supply Buyer's
Customers with partial requirements Energy supply in cases where Supplier is
providing a more standard Energy product that might not include load
forecasting, transmission and ancillary services, including imbalance charges,
then Buyer will assume greater risk related to some elements of Energy supply;
AND WHEREAS, in full or partial requirements Energy supply Transactions,
Buyer desires to, and Supplier may agree that Buyer may forego providing
Supplier with the usual level of Performance Assurance, such as a Letter of
Credit or cash, required to cover Seller's customary credit requirements to
ensure payment for Energy supply and certain Xxxx-to-Market fluctuations;
AND WHEREAS, Supplier agrees to assume certain limited credit risk because
Buyer has agreed: (i) to permit Supplier to monitor Buyer's credit management of
large Customer accounts; (ii) to grant Supplier certain operational and
financial oversight to its Michigan business; and (iii) to provide Supplier
Performance Assurance for all Wholesale Energy purchases made pursuant to a
Transaction and Confirmation. Such Performance Assurance shall be calculated
pursuant to the mutually agreed terms set forth in Exhibit B - Performance
Assurance Calculation (as such exhibit may be amended from time to time),
incorporated by reference and attached hereto.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the following mutual covenants,
agreements, and obligations, the Parties agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
DEFINITIONS
1.1 DEFINITIONS INCORPORATED BY REFERENCE FROM OTHER AGREEMENTS. ALL
initially capitalized terms not otherwise defined below or herein shall have the
meaning set forth in the EEI Master Agreement dated July 1, 2003, the Revised
Escrow Agreement dated October 27, 2004, or the Revised Security Agreement dated
October 27, 2004 executed between the Parties.
"Contract Quantity" means the agreed quantity of FRSP and/or PRSP for the
specified period as set forth below in Section 3.1 or as agreed to in various
Transaction(s).
"Customers" means the retail customers who have entered into the Retail
Contracts with Buyer as of the date of this Agreement, as identified on Exhibit
A. or such other retail customers as may become substituted Customers from time
to time.
"DECO Delivery Points means the delivery point for all Energy provided
hereunder to Customers in the DECo Program shall be the retail end use
Customer's meter(s).
"Full Requirements Service Product" or "FRSP" means firm Energy as
measured and delivered to the Customers' retail meters which shall include load
following energy, load forecasting and scheduling services, applicable Detroit
Edison and MISO transmission, and ancillary services charges, including
imbalance charges. The exact services included under a particular Transaction
will be set forth in the applicable Confirmation.
"Local Distribution Company" or "LDC" means The Detroit Edison Company.
"Load Factor" means the monthly and/or annual Energy (MWh) used by
Customers
divided by the product of the hours in the month and/or year and the peak demand
(MW) in the month and/or year.
"MISO" means the Midwest Independent System Operator.
"Off-Peak" means Mon to Fri Hour Ending ("HE") HE 0100 thru 0700 and HE
2400 EPT, and all 24 hours EPT on Saturdays, Sundays, and NERC holidays during
the Delivery Period of a Transaction(s).
"On-Peak" means Mon to Fri HE 800 thru HE 2300 EPT, excluding NERC
Holidays during the Delivery Period of a Transactions).
"Partial Requirements Service Product" or "PRSP" means firm Energy
measured and delivered to the Customers' retail meters which may include certain
Supplier services, such as scheduling services and certain applicable Detroit
Edison and MISO transmission, and ancillary services charges, including
imbalance charges. The exact services included under the particular Transaction
will be set forth in the applicable Confirmation.
"Retail Contracts" means each of the Energy Service Agreements, as such
agreements may be amended from time to time, entered into between Buyer and a
Customer, as identified on Exhibit A as such exhibit may be amended from time to
time.
"Retail Load" means, for any hour during the Delivery Period, the
aggregate FRSP and/or PRSP of the Retail Customers under the Retail Contracts,
as long as such aggregate FRSP and/or PRSP falls within the mutually agreed upon
parameters agreed to by the Parties.
ARTICLE 2
BUYER AND SUPPLIER OBLIGATIONS
2.1 BUYER OBLIGATIONS. Buyer shall provide all of the services and perform
all of its obligations under the Retail Contracts in accordance with: (i) the
terms of the Retail Contracts, (ii) all regulations applicable to an AES, (iii)
any applicable provisions of the relevant governing tariff(s), and (iv) the
provisions of this Agreement.
(a) Alternative Electric Supplier. Buyer shall act as an AES under
applicable regulations for all Customers receiving Energy purchased by
Buyer from Supplier under this Agreement, which includes, but is not
limited to, the following:
(i) Customer Enrollment: Buyer shall submit to the applicable
LDC a request for enrollment for each Customer in the DECo Program;
(ii) Assistance with Forecasting: Buyer shall provide Supplier
with the relevant data for analyzing the individual loads of each of
its Customers and the aggregate Retail Load, taking into account,
among other things, historical usage, weather conditions and other
system conditions, to forecast the anticipated Retail Load for each
hour during the Delivery Period;
(iii) Meter Data Management Services: Buyer shall, or shall
cause a commercially competent and qualified designee to, read,
validate, edit, and transfer meter data as required for calculation
of the xxxx to each Customer, and shall provide any other metering
or related data management services required by the Retail Contracts
for the Customers and provide Supplier with necessary interval
customer meter data to facilitate accurate forecasting and pricing;
(iv) Billing Services: Buyer shall calculate monthly bills for
each Customer in accordance with the applicable Retail Contract and
applicable meter data. Buyer or its commercially competent and
qualified designee shall deliver monthly bills to each Customer;
(v) Portfolio Accounting: Buyer shall work with Supplier to
maintain the accounts and records for the portfolio of electric
Energy sold and scheduled for delivery to Retail Load; and
(vi) Buyer's Data Obligations: Buyer shall provide Supplier's
appropriate sink identification to the LDC at time of Customer
enrollment, coordinate installation of phone lines, if required, for
all accounts under the DECo Program, notify Supplier when Customer
account commences and/or terminates with Buyer, provide each
Customer's information to Supplier, including Customer name,
address, electric utility rate code, historic billing information,
account number(s), meter number(s), load profile group, start and/or
termination date, significant Customer demand additions or
reductions, and any meter change information provided by the LDC.
(b) Revenues Deposited into Lockbox Account. Buyer shall deposit, or
cause to be deposited by each Customer and/or LDC, into the Lockbox
Account, any and all amounts owed to Buyer for sales of Energy and related
services to Customers under, pursuant to, or with respect to any Retail
Contract identified on Exhibit A.
2.2 TERMINATION OF A RETAIL CONTRACT. If a Retail Contract is terminated
for any reason prior to the end of the Delivery Period, then with respect to
that portion of the Contract Quantity represented by such terminated Retail
Contract ("Affected Quantity") during the remaining hours of the Delivery
Period, Buyer shall use its best efforts to locate and propose one or more
additional Customers to purchase part or all of such Affected Quantity. If the
product to be provided is FRSP and Buyer is unable to find any eligible
additional Customers, then the Affected Quantity shall revert to Supplier and
Buyer shall no longer be required to take delivery of, or pay for, such FRSP. In
the case ofPRSP, the terms and conditions of the Confirmation will control.
2.3 SUPPLIER OBLIGATIONS. Supplier shall provide all of the services and
perform all of its obligations under Transactions) in accordance with: (i) the
Retail Contracts, as applicable, (ii) all regulations applicable to a wholesale
supplier of an AES, (iii) any applicable provisions of the relevant governing
tariff(s), (iv) the provisions of this Agreement, and (v) whether the product
provided to Buyer is FRSP or PRSP.
(a) FRSP Obligations to Buyer. Supplier shall act as a wholesale
supplier of Energy under applicable regulations for all Customers
receiving Energy purchased by Buyer from Supplier under this Agreement,
which includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(i) Load Forecasting: Supplier shall analyze the individual
loads of the Customers and the aggregate Retail Load, taking into
account, among other things, historical usage, weather conditions
and other system conditions, to forecast the anticipated Retail Load
for each hour during the Delivery Period. Buyer may request and
Seller will provide its monthly load forecast from time to time;
(ii) Contract Pricing for Buyer Associated with Customers
Prior to Supplier's Issuance of a 7-Business Day Notice to Buyer. As
long as Supplier receives notice of such Buyer's acceptance of
Customer and Customer meets the appropriate criteria under the
relevant Transaction Program prior to Supplier's Issuance of a
7-Business Day Notice to Buyer for closure of that Transaction
Program. Supplier agrees that Buyer's Contract Price associated with
each Customer will remain fixed for a period of up to two (2) years.
Nothing in this part shall be construed to retroactively change the
pricing of Energy being delivered to Buyer and associated Customers
already acknowledged by Supplier as covered by a Transaction
Program.
(iii) Contract Pricing for Buyer Associated with Customers
Covered by the Transaction Program After Issuance of Supplier's
7-Business Day Notice to Buyer. Supplier will hold open each
Transaction Program to Buyer for new Customers for the earlier of:
six (6) months or until Buyer has allocated the maximum amount of
supply for its Customers; provided, however, that the relevant
Transaction Program will remain open to Buyer for new Customers
unless the volumetric, weighted average of the Cinergy On-Peak
forward market price for all available July, August, January, and
February months (within a window equal to the number of months of
the Customer term under the Delivery Period as set forth in each
relevant Transaction) beginning the third month after the month in
which each Transaction is executed, changes by more than 10% when
compared to the volumetric, weighted average of the Cinergy On-Peak
forward market price for all available July, August, January, and
February months (within the same window specified above) beginning
the third month after the current month for each day of the six (6)
month window. If the above-referenced forward market price change
threshold is triggered, then Supplier will provide Buyer a seven
(7)-Business Day notice that Supplier is closing the Transaction
Program to new Customers. During the pendency of the 7-Business Day
notice period. Buyer may finalize contract negotiations with new
Customers, as available, for up to ten percent (10%) of the maximum
amount of supply specified in the relevant Transaction; provided
however, that the maximum amount of supply to be provided under each
Transaction cannot exceed the maximum amount of supply specified in
each Transaction. After the notice period has expired, the
Transaction Program may be closed to new Customers. Upon acceptance
by Supplier of each Customer under the relevant
Transaction Program, Buyer's contract pricing associated with each
Customer remains in effect for up to two (2) years.
(iv) Load Following Energy: Supplier shall schedule and
deliver to each Customer, firm, full requirements Energy supply as
needed;
(v) Scheduling Transmission Services: Supplier shall schedule
with and purchase from the applicable transmission provider, network
integrated transmission service to ensure firm Energy delivery to
each Customer; and
(vi) Ancillary Services, including Imbalance Charges. Supplier
agrees to provide all ancillary services, and assume all imbalance
charge risk on behalf of Buyer's Customers.
(b) PRSP Obligations to Buyer. Supplier shall act as a wholesale
supplier of Energy under applicable regulations for Customers receiving
PRSP purchased by Buyer from Supplier under this Agreement, including, but
not limited to, the following:
(i) Load Forecasting: Supplier shall analyze the individual
loads of the Customers and the aggregate Retail Load, taking into
account, among other things, historical usage, weather conditions
and other system conditions, to forecast the anticipated Retail Load
for each hour during the Delivery Period. Buyer may request and
Seller will provide its monthly load forecast from time to time;
(ii) Energy: Supplier shall schedule and deliver to each
Customer firm, partial requirements Energy supply as needed and as
specified in the relevant Confirmation;
(iii) Scheduling Transmission Services: Supplier shall
schedule with and purchase from the applicable transmission
provider, network integrated transmission service to ensure firm
Energy delivery to each Customer; provided, however. Supplier may
pass through such costs to Buyer as appropriate under the terms of
the Confirmation; and
(vi) Ancillary Services, including Imbalance Charges. Supplier
agrees to provide all ancillary services, and assume all imbalance
charge risk on behalf of Buyer's Customers provided, however.
Supplier may pass through such costs to Buyer as appropriate under
the terms of the Confirmation.
(c) Credit Assistance to Buyer for FRSP and PRSP Transactions.
Supplier agrees to extend to Buyer, subject to the terms and conditions of
the EEI Master Agreement and related Confirmation(s), unsecured credit
equivalent to
approximately two months' Customer account receivables (to be posted to a
Lockbox Account). In addition, Buyer agrees to provide to Seller,
Performance Assurance pursuant to the methodology, calculations and data
set forth in Exhibit B.
2.4 SHARING OF DATA. Supplier and Buyer agree to cooperate and share
relevant data necessary to provide electric service to Customers. This may
include current and historical electricity usage data, payment and credit
history. Dun & Bradstreet number and other data reasonably necessary. In
addition, the Parties agree to share password-protected data and information
relevant to providing electric service to Customers under Transactions. Except
as otherwise specifically authorized by Customers or required by applicable law,
regulation, or court order, the Parties shall maintain, in confidence, all such
Customer data.
ARTICLE 3
CONTRACT QUANTITY AND CONTRACT PRICE OF ENERGY
3.1 DEFINITION OF CONTRACT QUANTITY. Subject to the terms of this
Agreement, during the relevant Delivery Period(s) set forth in a Transaction(s),
Supplier shall sell and deliver, or cause to be delivered, at the Delivery
Points, and Buyer shall purchase and receive, or cause to be received, at the
Delivery Points up to a maximum demand (MW) and an estimated volume of Energy
(MWh) of FRSP and/or PRSP at the Contract Price (the "Contract Quantity") during
each applicable hour of each specified month of the Delivery Period(s). Buyer
shall notify Supplier of any anticipated addition of Customers by notifying
Supplier of the expected increase or decrease in Retail Load as required under
Section 2.1 (a) herein.
3.2 BASIS FOR THE CONTRACT PRICE. Subject to Section 2 above, as
applicable, the Contract Price for each MWh of FRSP or PRSP is set according to
a fixed price for all Energy sold to Buyer's Customers associated with each
Transaction.
3.3 MANAGEMENT OF CONTRACT QUANTITY. Supplier agrees to submit the proper
documents to the MISO for each hour of the Delivery Period thereby scheduling
the delivery at the applicable Delivery Points of the applicable quantities of
Energy equal to the Contract Quantity.
ARTICLE 4
OPERATING ISSUES
4.1 PRIMARY SUPPLIER TO BUYER. Supplier will be the primary supplier to
Buyer for supplying its DECO Program Customers, under either an FRSP product or
PRSP product, as long as Supplier is willing to sell the FRSP or PRSP product to
Buyer at competitive prices.
If Buyer determines that an offer from Supplier for either an FRSP or PRSP
product is not competitive in the relevant market, Buyer has the right to seek
pricing from other suppliers for the Supplier-specified On-Peak and Off-Peak
Energy block components of the offered FRSP or PRSP product. Specifically, when
notified by Buyer that it intends to seek competitive offers for such On-Peak
and Off-Peak Energy block components. Supplier will provide Buyer with specific
data regarding the On-Peak and Off-Peak Energy blocks, e.g., size, delivery
point and associated terms and conditions, price for the respective Energy
blocks, and delivery period.
If Buyer receives an offer for the specified On-Peak and Off-Peak Energy
blocks (on terms substantially identical, as determined by Supplier, including
type of product and delivery point, to the terms specified by Supplier) from a
Third-Party Supplier ("TPS"), Buyer will advise Supplier of the TPS-offer terms
and conditions. Third Party Supplier means an entity that is not a Customer and
that agrees to sell electric power and/or transmission capacity to Buyer.
Supplier must either match the TPS offer or advise Buyer of its decision not to
match the offer. If Supplier matches the offer, it will be included in a revised
FRSP or PRSP offer to Buyer. If Supplier
declines to match the TPS offer, then Buyer may buy the specified Energy blocks
from the TPS and sell the specified Energy blocks to Supplier at the same offer
price as Buyer purchased the specified Energy blocks from the TPS. The terms and
conditions must be equivalent to the terms and conditions initially specified by
Supplier to Buyer. Supplier will then execute a FRSP or PRSP transaction with
Buyer at a price equal to the Supplier's purchase price for the specified Energy
blocks plus the difference between Supplier's initial FRSP or PRSP offer less
the price Supplier quoted Buyer for the specified Energy blocks.
4.2 CREDIT PROTECTIONS PROVIDED BY BUYER TO SUPPLIER. Buyer agrees: (i) to
require each Customer to send invoiced payments to a Lockbox Account as required
under the Revised Security Agreement and Revised Escrow Agreement, (ii) to
include the required Supplier assignment provision in each documented and
executed Retail Contract, (iii) to provide Supplier with the required
Performance Assurance pursuant to Exhibit B hereto; (iv) to provide Supplier
with copies of quarterly financial statements in the form of 10-K and 10-Q
statements filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission along with audited
or unaudited quarterly financial statements of Buyer; (v) to provide Supplier
with the right to review the creditworthiness and load attributes of potential
DECO Primary Supply Rate (D-6) customers; (v) to provide Supplier with all
contract terms and conditions for all documented and executed Retail Contracts;
(vi) to provide Supplier with Buyer's general credit policies and procedures;
and (vii) to provide Supplier, upon request, with a list of all other wholesale
Energy suppliers, the percentage of Buyer's total energy supply portfolio
represented by purchases from such other suppliers, and the regions in which the
transactions with the other suppliers occurred.
4.3 CREDIT ASSURANCES PROVIDED DIRECTLY BY CUSTOMERS. From time to time,
Buyer may, consistent with Section 5. CREDIT and Section 7. MATERIAL ADVERSE
CHANGE in Buyer's Master Retail Energy Supply Agreement, obtain a Letter of
Credit, prepayment, cash, or other collateral from a Customer associated with a
Transaction. In such instances, the Parties recognize that this form of credit
assurance is intended to inure to the benefit of both the Buyer and Supplier.
ARTICLE 5
REVISED SECURITY AND REVISED ESCROW AGREEMENTS
5.1 COMMITMENT TO COMPLETE. Supplier and Buyer have already executed a
Security Agreement and an Escrow Agreement. Within thirty (30) days of execution
of this Agreement, Supplier and Buyer shall execute a Revised Escrow Agreement
and a Revised Security Agreement.
5.2 CREDIT ASSURANCES PROVIDED BY CUSTOMERS. The relevant Escrow Account
shall be maintained during the entire Term of this Agreement, and thereafter
until all amounts due for Energy and related services sold to each Retail
Contract(s) entered into pursuant hereto shall have been settled per the Revised
Escrow Agreement and Revised Security Agreement.
ARTICLE 6
INVOICING, PAYMENT AND ACCOUNT RECONCILIATION
6.1 INVOICING AND PAYMENT. The Parties understand and agree that Supplier
invoicing shall initially be based on Energy delivered to Customers on a
calendar month basis modified for line losses. Once the Parties have agreed to
an invoice amount, Buyer shall prepare a Form of Distribution Request
("Distribution Request") for Supplier's final review and approval prior to
submission to the Escrow Agent for distribution. For example, if Supplier
delivers Energy to Customers during July 2004, Supplier shall use July delivery
data to create its July invoice payable under the September 2004 invoice for
Buyer's review. Customer invoiced payments received for July deliveries shall
accrue in the Lockbox/Escrow Account until the next
disbursement date occurs [September 2004]. Based on the Distribution Request
procedure set forth in the Revised Escrow Agreement, which is incorporated
herein by reference, the Parties shall discuss the September invoice initially
prepared by Supplier. The Parties shall cooperate to resolve any disputes over
invoices that arise. Buyer shall review and approve the undisputed portion of
Supplier's invoice. Based on that agreement of the Parties, Buyer shall then
prepare a Distribution Request for Supplier's final review and approval within
three (3) Business Days of Supplier's receipt of such Distribution Request,
prior to submission to the Escrow Agent. Once Supplier has approved and
delivered a fully-approved Distribution Request which appears to comply in all
material respects as required, the Escrow Agent shall make distributions as set
forth in the Revised Escrow Agreement by the EARLIER OF: two (2) Business Days
of receipt of a fully-approved Distribution Request, or by the twenty-fifth
(25th) day of the month, if a Business Day and a fully-approved Distribution
Request has been received. The Parties agree to follow this same procedure each
month. Billing adjustments shall be made, as appropriate, after Energy imbalance
information becomes available per Section 6.2 below.
6.2 ACCOUNT RECONCILIATION. Any disputed portions of the invoice, along
with any credits and charges due and owing either Party, based on Energy
imbalance data, and as modified for line losses, will be included in a
Reconciliation Charge/Credit submitted as part of the monthly invoice
subsequently provided to Buyer by Supplier. The Parties agree to expeditiously
resolve any and all disputes, and the Parties agree to follow this same
procedure each month. If the Parties are unable to resolve a payment dispute
through settlement checkout with each other, they agree to seek to resolve such
dispute through the Dispute Resolution procedure set forth herein in Article
8.4.
ARTICLE 7
PARTIES' RESPONSIBILITIES WITHIN THE DECO PROGRAM
7.1 THE DECO PROGRAM. Supplier shall function as a Marketer on behalf of
Buyer under the Marketer Agreement for Electric Choice Program between The
Detroit Edison Company and Supplier, and Buyer shall act as an AES/Retailer
under the AES/Retailer Agreement for Electric Choice Program between The Detroit
Edison Company and Buyer.
ARTICLE 8
MISCELLANEOUS ISSUES
8.1 CONFIDENTIALITY. The terms of this Agreement, including the
Transaction(s) hereunder, are confidential and are not to be disclosed to any
third Party without the prior written consent of the non-disclosing Party except
to the extent disclosure may be required by law, regulation or judicial or
administrative order.
8.2 GOVERNING LAW. This Agreement is to be construed under the laws of the
State of Michigan, without regard to any choice of law rules that would
otherwise require the application of the laws of another state. State and
federal courts situated in the State of Michigan shall have exclusive
jurisdiction to resolve any disputes with respect to this Agreement. Each Party
irrevocably consents to the jurisdiction described above for any actions, suits
or proceedings arising out of or relating to this Agreement.
8.3 CONFLICTING TERMS, hi the event of any conflict between the terms of
this Agreement and the terms of the EEI Master Agreement, the terms of this
Agreement shall control. In the event of any conflict between the terms of this
Agreement and any provision of the Revised Security Agreement or the Revised
Escrow Agreement, the terms of the Revised Security Agreement or the Revised
Escrow Agreement will control. In the event of any conflict between the terms of
this Agreement and the terms of a particular Confirmation, the terms of the
particular Confirmation shall control.
8.4 ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION. The Parties agree to seek to resolve
any dispute herein pursuant to good faith business negotiations. In the event of
such a dispute, the aggrieved Party shall promptly identify in writing the
nature of the outstanding dispute in sufficient detail so as to allow the other
Party to respond to the issue. Each Party agrees to (a) set a time and place for
a face-to-face meeting between a senior representative of each Party within 10
Business Days of written notice of the dispute, (b) identify in writing its own
position on the dispute, and (c) propose a resolution of the dispute. The
Parties agree to hold no fewer than one meeting within the time frame required
above in this Section 8.4(a) and to meet for at least a total of two hours at
the face-to-face meeting to discuss their respective positions and explore a
contractual resolution of the dispute. Such good faith procedures shall be a
condition precedent to any declaration of default by one Party against the
other, arbitration or litigation of the dispute.
8.5 ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Agreement, including the exhibits hereto,
contain the Parties' entire agreement relating to the subject matter hereof and
supersedes any other agreements, written or oral, between the Parties concerning
such subject matter. No amendment or alteration to this Agreement shall be
effective unless in writing and signed by the Parties.
8.6 NO WAIVER. No waiver at any time by any Party hereto of its rights
with respect to the other Party or with respect to any matter arising in
connection with this Agreement shall be considered a waiver with respect to any
subsequent default whether of a like kind or different in nature.
8.7 ASSIGNMENT. Neither Party may assign this Agreement or any right or
obligation under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other
Party, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld or delayed.
8.8 No PARTNERSHIP OR JOINT VENTURE. This Agreement does not establish and
should not be construed as establishing any partnership or joint venture by and
between the Parties, and neither Party shall have any duties, obligations or
liabilities arising under such a relationship. This Agreement shall not impart
any rights enforceable by any third party (other than a permitted successor or
assignee bound by this Agreement). The Parties acknowledge and agree that Buyer
is not in any way affiliated with Supplier and that Supplier is a wholesale
electricity provider contracted by Buyer solely to perform the activities set
forth herein and in the relevant agreements between them.
8.9 SEVERABILITY. If any provision of this Agreement is held invalid or
unenforceable, all other provisions shall not be affected. With respect to any
provision held invalid or unenforceable, the Parties shall amend or modify this
Agreement as necessary to effect as closely as possible the Parties' original
intent.
8.10 COUNTERPARTS. This Agreement may be executed in any number of
counterparts and each executed counterpart shall have the same force and effect
as an original instrument.
8.11 TERM. This Agreement shall continue indefinitely and shall terminate
only upon 30 days' prior written notice by one Party to the other Party;
provided, however, that such termination shall not affect or excuse the
performance of either Party under any provision of this Agreement that by its
terms survives any such termination, and, provided further, that this Agreement
and any other documents executed and delivered hereunder shall remain in effect
with respect to any Transaction(s) entered into prior to the effective date of
such termination until both Parties have fulfilled all of their obligations with
respect to such Transaction(s).
8.12 ASSUMPTION BY BUYER OF ANOTHER AES'S SALES CONTRACTS. In Supplier's
sole discretion, in the event that a Michigan alternative energy supplier
("AES") has defaulted under one or more of its agreements with Supplier, the
Parties shall agree that the following general principles and procedure would
apply: (1) Buyer would promptly assume AES customer sales contracts "AS IS" and
would simultaneously assume the wholesale supply arrangement between defaulted
AES and Supplier; (2) Supplier would furnish assurances to Buyer that a positive
margin exists between the defaulted AES's customer sales contracts and the
defaulted AES/Supplier supply contract; (3) Supplier would guarantee a minimum
dollar per MWh margin (to be determined based on the value of the defaulted AES
retail customer contracts portfolio or some other mutually agreed upon value,
e.g., $0.50 per MWh to cover the cost of operations); (4) Supplier would furnish
the defaulted AES customer portfolio in such a manner that would permit easy
review and assessment by Buyer, e.g., Supplier will denote non-standardized
language components in any defaulted AES customer sales contracts, e.g., varying
late fee payment to 1%, etc.; (5) Buyer would be prepared to issue notices
promptly to former defaulted AES customers regarding its assumption of the
defaulted AES customer sales contracts; and (6) Buyer would work with Supplier
to identify any additional steps that are necessary to complete Buyer's
assumption of the defaulted AES customer sales contracts and the defaulted
AES/Supplier supply contract(s).
8.13 NOTICES. Any notice required or given pursuant to this Agreement
("Notice") shall be in writing and delivered by means of private overnight
delivery, or by facsimile transmission, addressed as follows:
To Supplier:
DTE Energy Trading, Inc.
000 X. Xxxx Xxxxxx, Xxxxx 000
Xxx Xxxxx, XX 00000
Xxx: Xxxxxx Xxxxxxx, Contract Administration
Phone No.: 000.000.0000
Fax No.: 000.000.0000
To Buyer:
Commonwealth Energy Corporation
000 Xxxxx, 00xx Xxxxx
Xxxxx Xxxx, XX 00000
Attn: Xxxxxx Xxxxxx,
Vice President Energy Supply
Phone No.: (000)000-0000
Fax No.: (000) 000-0000
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties have caused this Agreement to be duly
executed as of the date first above written.
COMMONWEALTH ENERGY CORPORATION
By: /s/ Xxxxx Xxxxxxx
Its: President
("Debtor")
DTE ENERGY TRADING, INC.
By: /s/ Xxxxxxx X. Balhorm
Its: President
("Secured Party")
