Chapter Conclusion. Interest in 1 Corinthians and ancient education is on the rise. Though the scholarship of the mid-twentieth-century—especially the work of Judge, Malherbe, and Conzelmann—laid the tracks for future research, much of the work surveyed here saw publication at some point in the last decade. These works differ in kind, quality, and interpretation of the subject matter. Nevertheless, there appears to be a budding scholarly consensus that an informed reading of 1 Cor 1-4 must account for the educational motifs in these chapters. The scholarly projects surveyed above demonstrate the potential value of a clear and comprehensive statement regarding the nature, extent, and function of educational discourse in 1 Cor 1-4. To date, scholarship on education in 1 Corinthians has either focused on traditional research questions which have governed so much interpretation of 1 Corinthians since Baur (e.g., What was the Corinthian wisdom? Who were Paul’s opponents?), or demonstrated the importance of one facet of ancient Greek, Roman, or Jewish education (e.g., Hellenistic philosophy, the Jewish wisdom tradition). Much of this scholarship has implicitly assumed a stark (and outdated) division between Hellenistic and Jewish educational mores. In response to this need, the following chapters aim to describe the educational motifs in 1 Cor 1-4 on their own terms, in light of the educational systems which might have informed Paul’s language. It is to understanding these educational systems and their interrelationships that we now turn. Chapter 3:
Chapter Conclusion. This systematic review identified that while a large range of dynamic risk factors for inpatient aggression have been reported, a substantially smaller number demonstrate good levels of replicability and predictive ability. These risk factors were selected as candidates for the ESM and passive remote monitoring procedures used in later studies in this thesis, with Chapter 6 outlining the process by which the final set of dynamic risk factors was chosen. This review also highlighted multiple limitations of previous research which this thesis will address. For example, studies in this review typically used infrequent assessments of risk factors which were separated by days, weeks or months. These studies could therefore not investigate to what extent these risk factors vary over shorter periods of time and how these short-term changes relate to risk of future aggression. Chapter 5 outlines the process which assessed the optimal timeframes for identifying significant change in these risk factors, with Chapters 6, 7 and 8 investigating the magnitude of change over these timeframes and the relationship to aggression. Another key limitation of studies in this review was a lack of raters who were blind to the aggressive outcomes, raising the possibility that their risk ratings were influenced by the knowledge of service users’ aggressive behaviour. The remote monitoring methods used in this thesis overcame this limitation as risk factor ratings were separate from staff members’ recording of aggressive incidents. Chapter 3 Predicting Inpatient Aggression in Forensic Services Using Remote Monitoring Technology: Qualitative Study of Staff Perspectives The work presented in this chapter has been published: Xxxxx, X., Xxxxxxx, X., Xxxxx, X., & Xxxxx, T. (2019). Predicting inpatient aggression in forensic services using remote monitoring technology: qualitative study of staff perspectives. Journal of medical internet research, 21(9), e15620.
Chapter Conclusion. This study outlines how passive remote monitoring technology could offer numerous benefits to monitoring the risk of aggression in inpatient forensic mental health services from the perspective of staff working within these services. Multiple points related to feasibility and acceptability were raised, therefore it was considered prudent to conduct an initial pilot study (see Chapter 4). Another key theme raised by staff related to the clinical utility of remote monitoring, particularly the potential to identify relevant changes in risk factors before this escalated into aggression. Chapters 6, 7 and 8 present the results of studies conducted with service users to investigate this possibility. Many findings in this study also reflect issues which are beyond the scope of this thesis but should be addressed in future research. For example, participants identified a range of implementation barriers that need to be overcome to integrate remote monitoring effectively into current working practice. This reflects a wider issue in the literature with most novel prediction models in mental health failing to progress to the implementation stage (Xxxxxxx xx Xxxxx et al., 2020). Establishing appropriate policies and standards for data protection represents another key hurdle for the wider use of remote monitoring, requiring collaboration between service users, healthcare staff, researcher and digital health organisations (Xxxxxx et al., 2019). These issues and recommendations for future research are discussed in greater detail in Chapter 9.
Chapter Conclusion. This study investigated the acceptability and feasibility of ESM and passive remote monitoring procedures among a sample of forensic mental health staff and service users. Acceptability of remote monitoring is a key barrier to engagement, and it was essential to investigate this and highlight potential usability issues before progressing to the later studies reported in this thesis. Both ESM and passive remote monitoring were considered acceptable and feasible based on participant self-report and objective indices of device usage and data quality. A secondary aim was to compare the acceptability and feasibility of the Empatica E4 and Biovotion Everion, to select the optimal device to take forward in the future studies. Based on the findings the Empatica E4 was selected as the optimal device for use in future studies.
Chapter Conclusion. From the discussion above, we may conclude that the Territory’s social, cul- tural, and political norms have a significant resultant impact on the com- munity’s serious lack of (a) public knowledge and (b) public debate on non- economic and non-commercial issues. In particular, we may add, a serious level of public knowledge and of public debate on the social impact of mobile phone usage on children and young people. We opine that with better under- standing and knowledge of the capabilities and hazards of mobile usage, the 103 He, X., and Xxx, X.X. Xxxxxxxx., Regulating the New Media in China and Hong Kong: Manipulation and Transaction, available at Policy and Regulation in New Media: www. xxxxxxxx.xxxxx.xxx.xx/xxxxxxxx/xx0/xxxxx.xxxx 104 Supra. 105 The Basic Law is a mini constitution of Hong Kong. 106 Supra He and Xxx, n. 103. community as a whole will be able to participate actively and contribute creatively to a framework that best reflects the local culture, circumstance, and standard of morality, decency, and propriety. Whilst we observe that weak political will and public support due to the lack of public knowledge and public debate may be the result of (1) the Xxxxx- tory’s political tradition of a non-democratic form of governance which, we opine breeds democratic immaturity and (2) the Territory’s social and cultural norms which neither promotes the expression of collective public opinion nor encourages active community participation, we opine that the lessons we derive from the other jurisdictions are invaluable, and will provide a comprehensive guiding framework from which we can derive essential elements for the formulation of a viable framework for mobile content regulation.
