Final Liability Amount Sample Clauses

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for the violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. The proposed administrative civil liability is $309,140. Proposed Supplemental Environmental Project 1.

Final Liability Amount. The Final Liability Amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided the amount is within minimum and maximum liability amounts. The Combined Total Base Liability Amount was added to the investigation and enforcement costs accrued by the Los Angeles Water Board Prosecution Team. The Final Liability Amount is $7,382,447, which is within the minimum and maximum liability amounts.11 11 As explained in Section II, paragraph 12 of the Stipulated Order, the administrative civil liability was reduced to $6,000,000 under Enforcement Policy, section VI.B. (Settlement Considerations) in consideration of hearing and/or litigation risk. CALAS PARK STORMWATER AND WATER QUALITY IMPROVEMENTS SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECT WORKPLAN‌‌‌‌‌ PROPOSAL/ WORK PLAN REQUIREMENTS: Project Title: Calas Park Stormwater and Water Quality Improvements Supplemental Environmental Project (Calas Park SEP) Organization proposing the project (including project manager’s name, email address, and phone number; type of organization (public, private, non-profit, etc.): Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts (public) Project Manager: Xxxx Xxxxxxxxx, Supervising Engineer xxxxxxxxxx@xxxxx.xxx (000) 000-0000 extension 2811 Third party completing the project including all contact information (If applicable), including Project Manager Name & Contact Information: City of Xxxxxx (public) Project Manager: Xxxxxx Xxx, PE, Stormwater Engineer Xxxx@xxxxxxxx.xxx (000) 000-0000 extension 3523 Names and statement of qualifications and experience for Project Manager: Xxxxxx Xxx, XX Xxxxxx is a Licensed Civil Engineer (CA) with 9 years of experience in both public and private stormwater infrastructure projects, water quality analysis, and infrastructure maintenance. He received his B.S. in Civil Engineering with an emphasis on Environmental Hydrology from the University of California, Irvine in 2014. He also holds a B.S. in Biology from the University of California, San Diego. At the City of Xxxxxx, Xxxxxx works as the Stormwater Engineer managing and developing green infrastructure projects and managing MS4 permit compliance. Throughout his career, Xxxxxx has worked on a variety of projects related to stormwater, encompassing roles such as conceptual design, planning, grant funding, construction, post- construction review, maintenance, and water quality testing in both urban and natural infrastructure. His experience in both private and public enterprises prov...

Final Liability Amount. The stipulated administrative civil liability amount is $20,000, which includes $7,000 for staff costs (amounts rounded).

Final Liability Amount. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the final liability amount for failure to submit timely monitoring reports is $84,706.5. Economic Benefit Analysis Palm Springs Aerial Tramway - Valley Station Compliance Action One-Time Non-Depreciable Expenditure Non-Compliance Date Compliance Date Penalty Payment Date Discount Rate Benefit of Non- Compliance Amount Basis Date Delayed? June 2009 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 7ƒ16ƒ2009 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 4.00% 1,198 December 2009 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 1ƒ16ƒ2010 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 4.00% 1,186 September 2010 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 10ƒ16ƒ2010 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 4.00% 1,166 February 2011 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 3ƒ16ƒ2011 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 3.90% 1,146 October 2013 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 11ƒ16ƒ2011 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 3.90% 1,132 June 2016 Monthly Monitoring Report $ 1,000 ECI 6/13/2019 N 7ƒ16ƒ2016 − 6ƒ13ƒ2019 3.70% 1,039 Income Tax Schedule: USEPA BEN Model Version: Analyst: Date/Time of Analysis: Municipality Version 2019.0.0 (March 2019) Xxxxx Xxxxx 4ƒ29ƒ19 12:19 Total Benefit: $ 6,867

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. The proposed administrative civil liability is $4,037,620. Exhibit 1: Economic Benefit Analysis EXHIBIT 1 TO ADMINISTRATIVE CIVIL LIABILITY COMPLAINT R5-2016-0536 Economic Benefit Analysis Xxxxx Vocational Institution, Wastewater Treatment Facility Compliance Action Capital Investment One-Time Non-Depreciable Expenditure Annual Cost Non-Compliance Date Compliance Date Penalty Payment Date Discount Rate Benefit of Non- Compliance Amount Basis Date Delayed? Amount Basis Date Delayed? Amount Basis Date RO Plant Spare Parts Status Report $ 860,000 ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 1,306.38 ECI 10/13/2016 Y $ 7,656 ECI 1/1/2015 5/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 30 MBR Modules Replacement Time Schedule Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 653.19 ECI 10/13/2016 Y ECI 1/1/2015 5/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 16 Facility's O&M/SOP Updates ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 5,225.54 ECI 10/13/2016 Y ECI 1/1/2015 6/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 111 1st Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 4/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 1,000 2nd Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 7/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 997 3rd Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 10/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 993 4th Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 1/30/2016 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 989 MBR Replacement PCI 4/21/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 N ECI 1/1/2015 9/20/2012 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 4.00% $ 2,042,025 Procurement of Spare Parts ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 250,000 PCI 4/30/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 8/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 4,844 Annual MBR Removal & Cleaning ECI 1/1/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 N ECI 10/13/2016 9/20/2011 1/1/2016 1/1/2016 4.10% $ 33,769 Income Tax Schedule: Municipality Analyst: Xxxxx Xxxxx Total Benefit: $ 2,084,774 USEPA BEN Model Version: Version 5.5.0 (July 2015) Date/Time of Analysis: 5/31/2016 11:40 Assunptions: 1 RO Plant Spare Parts Status Report based on 20 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 2 MBR Modules Replacement Time Schedule Report based on 10 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 3 Facilities O&M/SOP Updates based on 80 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 4 Quarterly Reports based on 15 hours for CDCR Water & Sew...

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the total base liability, with any allowed adjustments, provided the amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. The final liability amount proposed for the alleged Water Code violations was performed as follows:

Final Liability Amount. Based on the liability calculation methodology, the proposed civil liability for 8 days of discharge and 163,461 gallons of discharged material in violation of the WDRs and NPDES permit is $ 674,306, including staff costs. This amount reflects the appropriate amount over the minimum penalty required by law. MMPs have been issued and paid for more than the past ten years, and yet the effluent violations continue. The recommended penalty is designed to dissuade the Discharger from viewing continued water quality impacts and additional MMPs as a cost of doing business. Enclosed: Exhibit 1 – Effluent Exceedances EXHIBIT 1 – EFFLUENT EXCEEDANCES FOR XXXXX FACILITY VIOLATION PERIOD DECEMBER 1, 2020 THROUGH MARCH 31, 2022 Violation Date Discharge Point Violation Type Parameter Reported Value Permit Limit Units Pollutant Category % Exceeded 12/28/20 001 Single Sample Max E. coli* 490 235 MPN/100 mL OEV NA 12/28/20 001 Daily Max Copper 32 17 µg/L 2 88% 12/28/20 001 Daily Max Selenium 29 8.2 µg/L 2 254% 12/28/20 001 Daily Max Zinc 410 159 µg/L 2 158% 12/28/20 001 Daily Max Chronic Toxicity* Fail Pass, % Effect <50 NA OEV NA 01/29/21 001 Daily Max Copper 43 17 µg/L 2 153% 01/29/21 001 Daily Max Selenium 22 8.2 µg/L 2 168% 01/29/21 001 Daily Max Zinc 680 159 µg/L 2 328% 01/29/21 002 Instant Max pH 9.42 8.5 SU OEV NA 01/29/21 002 Single Sample Max E. coli 330 235 MPN/100 mL OEV NA 01/29/21 002 Daily Max Turbidity 110 75 NTU OEV NA 01/29/21 002 Daily Max Copper 21 17 µg/L 2 24% 01/29/21 002 Daily Max Selenium 71 8.2 µg/L 2 766% 01/29/21 002 Daily Max Zinc 390 159 µg/L 2 145% 01/29/21 002 Daily Max TSS 130 75 mg/L 2 73% Violation Date Discharge Point Violation Type Parameter Reported Value Permit Limit Units Pollutant Category % Exceeded 01/29/21 002 Daily Max TCDD equiv. 6.2E-07 2.8E-08 µg/L 2 2,114% 03/03/21 001 Instantaneous Max pH 8.83 8.5 SU OEV NA 03/03/21 001 Daily Max BOD 31 30 mg/L 1 3% 03/03/21 001 Daily Max Copper 57 17 µg/L 2 235% 03/03/21 001 Daily Max Selenium 170 8.2 µg/L 2 1,973% 03/03/21 001 Daily Max Zinc 430 159 µg/L 2 170% 03/15/21 001 Daily Max Selenium 23 8.2 µg/L 2 180% Daily Max Zinc 270 159 µg/L 2 70% 10/25/21 001 Single Sample Max E. coli* 460 235 MPN/100 mL OEV NA 10/25/21 001 Daily Max Copper 47 17 µg/L 2 176% 10/25/21 001 Daily Max Selenium 88 8.2 µg/L 2 973% 10/25/21 001 Daily Max TCDD equiv. 2.99E-06 2.8E-08 µg/L 2 10,579% 10/25/21 001 Daily Max TCDD equiv. 1.32E-05 3.80E-06 lbs/day 2 247% 10/25/21 001 Daily Max Zinc 1,100 159 µg/L 2 592% 1...

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. Without further investigation of the discharge, calculation of economic benefits, and additional staff time, the proposed Administrative Civil Liability is eight hundred thousand sixty-one dollars ($800,061). Attachment B – ACL Order R5-2013-0545 Supplemental Environmental Project Description SFPUC Priest Reservoir 5-9 December 2011 Discharge

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the amount of the violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided the amount is within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. Using the Penalty Calculation Methodology, as described above, the proposed penalty is $235,760. COTTONWOOD WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT‌ CALCULATION OF MANDATORY MINIMUM PENALTIES (Data reported under Monitoring and Reporting Program No. R5-2010-0044 and R5-2016-0066) EFFLUENT LIMITATION VIOLATIONS – MONITORING LOCATION EFF-001 Violation Date Parameter Units Condition Final Effluent Limit Reported Value Violation Type CIWQS ID MMP Amount 12/16/2013 pH SU Instantaneous Maximum 8.5 9.2 OEV 961627 1 12/17/2013 pH SU Instantaneous Maximum 8.5 9.1 OEV 961624 1 12/20/2013 pH SU Instantaneous Maximum 8.5 8.7 OEV 961621 1 2/12/2014 pH SU Instantaneous Minimum 6.5 6.4 OEV 995027 $3,000 11/14/2014 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 28 OEV 983167 N/A 4/27/2015 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 127 OEV 995002 N/A 4/30/2015 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 127 OEV 995003 N/A 11/27/2015 pH SU Instantaneous Minimum 6.5 6.4 OEV 1000290 N/A 12/03/2015 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 89 OEV 1002004 N/A 12/21/2015 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 97 OEV 1002005 N/A Violation Date Parameter Units Condition Final Effluent Limit Reported Value Violation Type CIWQS ID MMP Amount 8/2/2016 Total Chlorine Residual mg/L 1-Hour Average 0.019 0.051 Serious Group II 1012656 $3,000 12/12/2016 pH SU Instantaneous Minimum 6.5 6.1 OEV 1017997 N/A 1/1/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 130 OEV 1020568 N/A 2/1/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 50 OEV 1022777 N/A 2/5/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 80 OEV 1022778 $3,000 4/16/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 50 OEV 1024866 $3,000 5/4/2017 Chlorodibromom ethane µg/L Final MDEL 4.3 4.84 Non- Serious Group II 1034196 $3,000 5/31/2017 Chlorodibromom ethane µg/L Final AMEL 2.2 4.84 Serious Group II 1027046 $3,000 5/31/2017 Dichlorobromom ethane µg/L Final AMEL 10.6 16.8 Serious Group II 1027047 $3,000 6/27/2017 pH SU Instantaneous Minimum 6.5 6.3 OEV 1045908 $3,000 11/19/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 36 OEV 1035864 $3,000 11/26/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 66 OEV 1035866 $3,000 12/1/2017 Total Coliform Organisms MPN/100 mL 7-day Median 23 80 OE...

Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the final proposed Administrative Civil Liability is $288,288. EXHIBIT B TO ORDER R5-2017-0525‌ Supplemental Environmental Project (SEP) Proposal: City of Marysville‌ Project Title: Algae Bloom Reduction in Ellis Lake Name of Responsible Entity: City of Marysville Geographic Area of Interest: Yuba River and Feather River Water Body, beneficial use and/or pollutant addressed by this project: Ellis Lake, algae, Xxxx Xxxxxx, Feather River Estimated Cost for Project Implementation: $172,430 Contact Information: Xxxxxx Xxxxxxxxxxx City Manager, City of Marysville, CA 526 “C” Street Marysville, CA 95901 (000) 000-0000 xxxxxxxxxxxx@xxxxxxxxxx.xx.xx. Overview: Ellis Lake is a man-made lake centered in downtown Marysville, bordered by 9th Street to the south, B Street to the east, 14th Street to the North and D Street to the West. The lake is fed by urban runoff and was historically supplemented by pumped water from the Yuba River. Ellis Lake has a surplus of algae blooms contributing to poor water quality. The surplus of algae blooms in Ellis Lake has been an issue for the community for a number of years, but no previous scientific investigation, feasibility, or engineering work with respect to implementing a solution has been conducted. Ellis Lake discharges to Xxxx Xxxxxx, which feeds the Feather River, typically during the wet season. The City of Marysville (City) is proposing to prepare a Technical Memorandum (TM) to analyze potential alternatives to address dissolved oxygens levels in Ellis Lake to improve water quality and reduce the prevalence of algae, and then to implement the selected project. The project will be based on two alternatives, or possibly, a combination of alternatives, pursuant to the findings in the TM. The two alternatives to be analyzed in the TM are as follows: