Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory maximum and minimum amounts. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the final proposed Administrative Civil Liability is forty-two thousand three hundred and fifty-three dollars ($42,353).
Final Liability Amount. The Final Liability Amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided the amount is within minimum and maximum liability amounts. The Combined Total Base Liability Amount was added to the investigation and enforcement costs accrued by the Los Angeles Water Board Prosecution Team. The Final Liability Amount is $7,382,447, which is within the minimum and maximum liability amounts.11 11 As explained in Section II, paragraph 12 of the Stipulated Order, the administrative civil liability was reduced to $6,000,000 under Enforcement Policy, section VI.B. (Settlement Considerations) in consideration of hearing and/or litigation risk. CALAS PARK STORMWATER AND WATER QUALITY IMPROVEMENTS SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECT WORKPLAN Calas Park Stormwater and Water Quality Improvements Supplemental Environmental Project (Calas Park SEP) Los Angeles County Sanitation Districts (public) Project Manager: Xxxx Xxxxxxxxx, Supervising Engineer (000) 000-0000 extension 2811 City of Xxxxxx (public) Project Manager: Xxxxxx Xxx, PE, Stormwater Engineer (000) 000-0000 extension 3523 Xxxxxx is a Licensed Civil Engineer (CA) with 9 years of experience in both public and private stormwater infrastructure projects, water quality analysis, and infrastructure maintenance. He received his B.S. in Civil Engineering with an emphasis on Environmental Hydrology from the University of California, Irvine in 2014. He also holds a B.S. in Biology from the University of California, San Diego. At the City of Xxxxxx, Xxxxxx works as the Stormwater Engineer managing and developing green infrastructure projects and managing MS4 permit compliance. Throughout his career, Xxxxxx has worked on a variety of projects related to stormwater, encompassing roles such as conceptual design, planning, grant funding, construction, post- construction review, maintenance, and water quality testing in both urban and natural infrastructure. His experience in both private and public enterprises provide a solid foundation to guide the effective development and management of stormwater projects. Xxxxxx’s experience with multi-benefit stormwater infrastructure is extensive. He has worked on several public stormwater projects, notably: South Los Angeles Wetlands Park, Mar Vista Recreation Park BMP, Echo Park Lake Rehabilitation, and the City of Xxxxxx’x Carriage Crest Park Stormwater facility. He also has experience in designing and reviewing stormwater treatment and capt...
Final Liability Amount. $124,238 Applicant: Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and the Environment Project Title: Newhall Creek Community Watershed Education and Restoration Project Amount requested: $100,896 Project duration: 32 months Project Description: Newhall Creek (Creek), a tributary of the Santa Xxxxx River, runs through the community of Newhall and past the XxXxxxx Elementary School in the largely Spanish speaking area and disadvantaged community of Santa Clarita. The Creek, still natural in some areas, and rip-rapped or soft-bottom hardscaped in others, is often called "the Wash." It is littered with trash and the native flora is sometimes dominated by the invasive Arundo donax. Several drinking water xxxxx are located downstream from this section of the Creek.
1) Lessons on watershed issues and its connection to water supply and water quality through hands on demos and projects.
2) Supervised watershed related field trips.
3) Creek clean-ups to improve water quality, involving both parents and students.
4) Student-led water quality testing.
5) Inclusion and growth of native riparian plants in the school's garden project for re- vegetation.
Final Liability Amount. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the final liability amount for failure to submit timely monitoring reports is $72,909.
Final Liability Amount. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the proposed administrative civil liability is $114,606, which includes $3,000 for staff costs.
Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. The proposed administrative civil liability is $4,037,620. Exhibit 1: Economic Benefit Analysis RO Plant Spare Parts Status Report $ 860,000 ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 1,306.38 ECI 10/13/2016 Y $ 7,656 ECI 1/1/2015 5/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 30 MBR Modules Replacement Time Schedule Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 653.19 ECI 10/13/2016 Y ECI 1/1/2015 5/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 16 Facility's O&M/SOP Updates ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 5,225.54 ECI 10/13/2016 Y ECI 1/1/2015 6/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 111 1st Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 4/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 1,000 2nd Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 7/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 997 3rd Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 10/30/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 993 4th Quarter 2015 Report ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 979.79 ECI 10/13/2016 N ECI 1/1/2015 1/30/2016 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 989 MBR Replacement PCI 4/21/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 N ECI 1/1/2015 9/20/2012 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 4.00% $ 2,042,025 Procurement of Spare Parts ECI 1/1/2015 Y $ 250,000 PCI 4/30/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 8/1/2015 10/13/2016 10/13/2016 3.60% $ 4,844 Annual MBR Removal & Cleaning ECI 1/1/2015 Y ECI 1/1/2015 N ECI 10/13/2016 9/20/2011 1/1/2016 1/1/2016 4.10% $ 33,769 Income Tax Schedule: Municipality Analyst: Xxxxx Xxxxx Total Benefit: $ 2,084,774 USEPA BEN Model Version: Version 5.5.0 (July 2015) Date/Time of Analysis: 5/31/2016 11:40 1 RO Plant Spare Parts Status Report based on 20 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 2 MBR Modules Replacement Time Schedule Report based on 10 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 3 Facilities O&M/SOP Updates based on 80 labor hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 4 Quarterly Reports based on 15 hours for CDCR Water & Sewage Plant Supervisor. 5 MBR Replacement costs based on GE Water & Process Technologies Proposal (4/21/2015). Product warrantied for 24 months, which has been used as replacement life.
Final Liability Amount. The final liability amount consists of the added amounts for each violation, with any allowed adjustments, provided amounts are within the statutory minimum and maximum amounts. Using the Penalty Calculation Methodology, as described above, the final liability amount is $378,668. ATTACHMENT C SUPPLEMENTAL ENVIRONMENTAL PROJECT
1. Project Name
Final Liability Amount. $ 276,482
Final Liability Amount. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the 2010 Enforcement Policy, the final administrative civil liability amount, including staff costs, is 2. U.S. EPA BEN Economic Benefit Analysis Table
1. Select Potential Harm for Discharge Violations
2. Select Characteristics of the Discharge
3. Select Susceptibility to Cleanup or Abatement
4. Select Deviation from Standard
5. Click "Determine Harm & per Gallon/Day…"
6. Enter Values into the Yellow highlighted fields Potential Harm Factor (Generated from Button) Per Gallon Factor (Generated from Button) Gallons Statutory Maximum High Volume Per Day Factor (Generated from Button) Days Statutory Max per Day Per Day Factor Total Days Multiple Day Violation Reduction Statutory Max per Day Culpability Cleanup and Cooperation History of Violations Maximum for this Violation Amount for this Violation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2 246 14 0.3 171 11 0.4 757 31 0.4 391 19 0.4 572 25 0.4 405 19 0.4 402 19 0.7 441 20 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $ 1,000 $
1.1 1
Final Liability Amount. Based on the foregoing analysis, and consistent with the Enforcement Policy, the Final Liability Amount is the sum of the Total Base Liability Amount and other factors as justice may require totaling $193,879.
